Project 112 and Project SHAD: the 1960s nerve-agent and germ tests on US troops
From 1962 to 1973 the Pentagon ran secret chemical and biological tests at sea and on land. It began looking into them in 2000, and admitted in 2002 that sarin and VX were used.
What’s claimed
For decades, Navy veterans said they had been sprayed with something during secret tests in the Pacific in the 1960s, and that the military would not admit the tests had happened. The programme they described was Project 112, a classified Defence Department effort to test chemical and biological warfare agents, and its sea-going part, Project SHAD (Shipboard Hazard and Defense). The claim: American servicemen were exposed to live nerve agents and germs, often without being told, and the government kept quiet about it.
What’s on the record
The tests were real. The Deseret Test Center, headquartered at Fort Douglas in Salt Lake City, Utah, planned 134 tests between 1962 and 1973; the Pentagon’s own investigation later confirmed that 50 were carried out and 84 were not, according to the Military Health System. The sea tests were meant to find out how vulnerable US warships were to chemical or biological attack; the land tests studied how agents behaved in different climates.
The Deseret News revealed Project SHAD in 1995 from documents released under the Freedom of Information Act, and reported that veterans’ disability claims had been turned down. In 2000, CBS News correspondent Vince Gonzales reported on more than 100 secret biological warfare tests at sea. That September, at the request of the Department of Veterans Affairs, the Defence Department began its own investigation.
In May 2002 the Pentagon acknowledged for the first time that some SHAD tests used real warfare agents, not just harmless stand-ins. CBS News reported that four Pacific tests from 1964 to 1968 used sarin, VX or a biological toxin. In 1964 sarin was used in a test off Hawaii, and was sprayed on the USS George Eastman and injected into its ventilation system; in 1968 staphylococcal enterotoxin B was sprayed over five tugboats, the USS Granville S. Hall and parts of a Pacific atoll. Crews sheltered in sealed compartments or wore masks and protective suits.
When the Pentagon released its final findings in January 2004, it had identified 5,842 service members present for at least one test, many of whom had not been told they were taking part, CBS reported; land tests took place in Hawaii, Alaska, Maryland, Florida, Utah, Georgia, Panama, Canada and Britain. The Pentagon concluded that participants “should have been fully informed of the details of each test.” The Military Health System now puts the count at 6,400.
What doesn’t add up
What the exposures did to the men is far less clear. The Defence Department says its records show no one died as a result of a Deseret Test Center test, and a Defence health official, Dr. Michael Kilpatrick, said none of the tests was meant to measure the human response to the agents. A 2007 Institute of Medicine report suggested more deaths from heart disease among SHAD veterans, but a follow-up that Congress requested in 2010, covering about 5,900 veterans, found no significant increase in illness or deaths compared with similar servicemen. That committee noted the tests were more than 50 years old and that it had been refused some classified sampling data. Even the name is muddled: the Pentagon says Shipboard Hazard and Defense, while the Deseret News reported Ship Habitation And Decontamination.
Still open
What the exposures did to the men has been studied, and the largest follow-up, requested by Congress in 2010 and covering about 5,900 veterans, found no significant increase in illness or deaths. That committee noted it was refused some classified sampling data, and a Defence health official said none of the tests was meant to measure how people responded. The count of men present has moved too, from 5,842 to 6,400.
Where it stands (for now)
Declassified. The Pentagon has confirmed the tests, the live agents and the thousands of servicemen present, many of them never told they were taking part. The largest follow-up study so far found no significant increase in illness or deaths among them.
Sources
- Document Project 112/Shipboard Hazard and Defense (SHAD) · Military Health System (US Department of Defense)
- Document Project 112/Project SHAD · US Department of Veterans Affairs
- News Nerve Gas Used On Sailors In '60s Tests · CBS News · May 23, 2002
- News Sailors exposed to deadly agents · Deseret News · May 23, 2002
- News DoD Tested Weapons On Thousands · CBS News (Associated Press) · Jan. 15, 2004
- Document No Significant Increase in Health Risks for 1960s Project SHAD Veterans, Says New Report · National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine
More: the case files, every source behind every story.