Project A119: the 1958 US Air Force study of a nuclear blast on the Moon
In 1958 and 1959 the US Air Force paid Chicago physicists, a young Carl Sagan among them, to study exploding a nuclear bomb on the Moon. It surfaced in 2000 and never left paper.
What’s claimed
Project A119, also known by the title of its report, A Study of Lunar Research Flights, was a secret United States Air Force study of what would happen if a nuclear weapon were set off on or near the Moon. The work was done in 1958 and early 1959 at the Armour Research Foundation in Chicago, now part of the Illinois Institute of Technology, under the physicist Leonard Reiffel. One of the young scientists on the team was Carl Sagan. Online, the story is usually told as a Cold War plan to blow up the Moon.
What’s on the record
The study is real. Reiffel told The Observer in May 2000 that senior Air Force officers approached him in 1958 and asked him to fast-track a study of the visibility and effects of a nuclear explosion on the Moon. He said he produced eight reports between May 1958 and January 1959, and that the foundation destroyed them in 1987. Volume I of A Study of Lunar Research Flights, prepared for the Air Force Special Weapons Center at Kirtland Air Force Base in New Mexico and listed with a date of 19 June 1959, is now posted by the National Security Archive at George Washington University. The Archive describes it as a study of a detonation on or near the lunar surface, covering the blast, heat flow, seismic readings, radiation and the Moon’s magnetic field, and says a second volume holds two chapters that are probably still sensitive.
Sagan’s job was mathematical modelling: how a cloud of dust thrown up by the blast would spread in the space around the Moon, which was the key to working out whether it could be seen from Earth. Scientists still wondered then whether the Moon held microbes, and Sagan had suggested a blast might help detect them. The project came to light because his biographer, Keay Davidson, found that Sagan had mentioned the classified work when he applied for a Miller Institute graduate fellowship at Berkeley. Reiffel then came forward. He told The Observer the main aim was “a PR exercise and a show of one-upmanship,” and wrote to the journal Nature that, in his opinion, Sagan had breached security in March 1959.
What doesn’t add up
The bigger versions of the story are not on the record. In 2012, aged 85, Reiffel told CNN the device would not have blown up the Moon and would have been essentially invisible from Earth, even through a good telescope. The Observer had written in 2000 that the bomb would have been at least the size of the one dropped on Hiroshima; Reiffel told CNN he was not part of those discussions, and other accounts call it an H-bomb. The historian Vince Houghton, writing for History.com in 2019, notes that with no air there could be no mushroom cloud, only a flash and a spreading cloud of dust.
Why it was dropped is also unsettled. Reiffel told CNN the scientists did not want to add radioactivity from Earth to the Moon, and CNN reported doubts about the weapons’ reliability and fear of a public backlash. Houghton writes that the final reason is still unclear. In 2000 a Pentagon spokesman would neither confirm nor deny the plan.
Still open
Reiffel said he wrote eight reports and that the foundation destroyed them in 1987. Only Volume I of the 1959 study is public; the National Security Archive says a second volume holds two chapters that are probably still sensitive. Why the project was dropped is unsettled, and in 2000 a Pentagon spokesman would neither confirm nor deny the plan. That second volume would tell us more.
Where it stands (for now)
Declassified. The Air Force study, its Chicago team and Sagan’s part are on the record, along with one released volume of the report. No document so far shows a plan to destroy the Moon, a settled size for the bomb or any decision to go ahead.
Sources
- Document Soldiers, Spies and the Moon: Secret U.S. and Soviet Plans from the 1950s and 1960s (Electronic Briefing Book No. 479) · National Security Archive, George Washington University · July 19, 2014
- Document A Study of Lunar Research Flights, Volume I (Armour Research Foundation for the Air Force Special Weapons Center) · National Security Archive, George Washington University · June 18, 1959
- News US planned one big nuclear blast for mankind · The Observer (The Guardian) · May 13, 2000
- News U.S. military considered detonating nuclear bomb on the moon · CNN, via FOX6 Milwaukee · Nov. 27, 2012
- News Why the Air Force Almost Blasted the Moon with an H-Bomb (Vince Houghton) · History.com · July 4, 2019
More: the case files, every source behind every story.