Project Blue Book and the Condon Report: how the Air Force closed the UFO file
From 1952 to 1969 the US Air Force’s Project Blue Book logged thousands of UFO reports before a university study recommended shutting it down; the CIA’s own history shows the public was not told everything, though not for the reason believers think.
What’s claimed
For 17 years, Project Blue Book was the US Air Force’s official answer to flying saucers. Critics have long argued that it was less an investigation than a public-relations exercise meant to make the subject go away, and that the University of Colorado study that recommended closing it, known as the Condon Report, reached a conclusion settled before the work began. Some go further and say the Air Force was hiding proof of visitors.
What’s on the record
The Air Force began collecting reports in 1947 under Project Sign, which became Project Grudge. In 1952 its director of intelligence, Maj. Gen. Charles Cabell, ordered a new project, and Blue Book became the main effort, according to a history of the CIA’s role published in 1997. Blue Book was run from Wright-Patterson Air Force Base in Ohio. By the National Archives’ count, it received 12,618 reports from 1947 to 1969 and left 701 unidentified.
In January 1953 a CIA-sponsored panel of scientists chaired by the physicist H. P. Robertson found no direct threat to national security and no evidence that the objects were extraterrestrial. It also recommended that the National Security Council debunk UFO reports, run a public-education campaign through the mass media (even the Disney corporation was suggested), and watch civilian UFO groups for subversive activity.
The same CIA history says that once the U-2 spy plane began test flights in 1955, pilots and air traffic controllers reported a surge in sightings. Blue Book investigators who knew about the U-2 explained many of them away as ice crystals or temperature inversions. CIA officials later estimated that manned reconnaissance flights accounted for over half of all UFO reports from the late 1950s through the 1960s, and the history says this led the Air Force to make "misleading and deceptive statements" to the public.
In October 1966 the Air Force contracted the University of Colorado to run an independent study under the physicist Edward Condon. Its report, released in early 1969, concluded that nothing from 21 years of UFO study had added to scientific knowledge and that further extensive study probably could not be justified. A National Academy of Sciences panel agreed, calling extraterrestrial visitation the least likely explanation. On December 17, 1969, Air Force Secretary Robert Seamans Jr. announced the end of Blue Book. Its files went to the National Archives in 1976.
What doesn’t add up
The critics have real material. On August 9, 1966, the project’s coordinator, Robert Low, wrote in an internal memo that "the trick would be, I think, to describe the project so that, to the public, it would appear a totally objective study." When the memo surfaced, two staff scientists were dismissed, and Low resigned in May 1968 after Look magazine reported the affair. Critics also pointed out that the study could not adequately explain more than a quarter of the cases it examined. Blue Book’s own chief scientific adviser, the astronomer J. Allen Hynek, was publicly criticized by Gerald Ford, then a Michigan congressman, after attributing a 1966 Michigan sighting to college pranks or swamp gas.
What the record does not show is any sign that the unidentified cases concealed alien craft. The CIA history, frank about the deception, says the secret being protected was America’s own spy planes.
Still open
Of 12,618 reports, 701 are still listed as unidentified in Blue Book’s files. CIA officials estimated that manned reconnaissance flights explain over half of all reports from the late 1950s through the 1960s, but the history quoted here doesn’t say which cases those were. The Colorado study could not adequately explain more than a quarter of the cases it examined. Matching those files against the spy flights would tell us how much of the unknown was ours.
Where it stands (for now)
Redacted. Documents show officials recommended debunking, the Air Force misled the public to protect the U-2, and the Colorado study’s coordinator wrote about making it appear objective. That supports the charge that the official inquiry was shaped to reassure; nothing in the record so far suggests it was hiding visitors.
Sources
-
Document
Project BLUE BOOK - Unidentified Flying Objects
· U.S. National Archives and Records Administration
“Of these 701 remain "Unidentified."” - Document CIA's Role in the Study of UFOs, 1947-90 (Gerald K. Haines, Studies in Intelligence) · Central Intelligence Agency, Center for the Study of Intelligence · Dec. 31, 1996
- Source 50 Years Ago: Government Stops Investigating UFOs · National Archives Foundation · Dec. 4, 2019
- Source Condon Committee · Wikipedia
-
News
Remembering NU professor J. Allen Hynek’s UFO research
· The Daily Northwestern · March 5, 2023
“Hynek later became chief scientific advisor for Project Blue Book, an Air Force study of UFOs from 1947 to 1969.”
More: the case files, every source behind every story.