Project Habbakuk: the secret ice aircraft carrier tested on Patricia Lake, Alberta
In 1943 Britain and Canada secretly built a model ice ship on Patricia Lake near Jasper to test Geoffrey Pyke’s plan for an aircraft carrier made of ice; its remains still lie on the lake bed.
What’s claimed
It sounds like a story told around a Jasper campfire: during the Second World War the Allies tried to build an aircraft carrier out of ice, and what is left of the test model sits at the bottom of a mountain lake in Alberta. The project went by the code name Habbakuk (often spelled Habakkuk), and the story is true.
What’s on the record
The idea came from Geoffrey Pyke, a British inventor. In October 1942 he proposed hollowing out a natural or artificial iceberg to shelter aircraft, with a levelled runway on top, arguing that ice took only about one per cent of the energy needed to make the same weight of steel, the crystallographer Max Perutz, who worked on the project, wrote in 1948. Pure ice is brittle, but researchers found that freezing water with a little wood pulp made a far tougher material, named pykrete after Pyke; Perutz credited its discovery to Mark and Hohenstein at the Brooklyn Polytechnic in 1943 and wrote that it could even be machined on a lathe. Cabinet magazine recounts the famous demonstrations: Lord Louis Mountbatten dropping a block of ice into Winston Churchill’s bath at Chequers in late 1942 and, at the Quebec Conference in August 1943, firing at a block of pykrete only for the bullet to ricochet.
Canada’s National Research Council ran the research here. Early in 1943 a model was built on Patricia Lake, in what is now Jasper National Park: about 18 metres long and 9 metres wide (60 by 30 feet), weighing roughly 1,000 tonnes, made of blocks of lake ice with refrigeration pipes and roofed over to look like a boathouse. Conscientious objectors from alternative service camps, including Mennonites, did much of the labour. One of them recalled for the Mennonite Historian in 2003 that the men cut and dragged out the ice blocks and were told little about what they were building. The refrigeration was switched off in June, and the ice lasted through the summer before the model sank.
The full-size ship was never built. Perutz described a runway 600 metres long, a displacement of about 2.2 million tonnes and a plant covering some 100 acres to make the pykrete. The plan was dropped early in 1944: the scale was enormous, aircraft ranges had grown and island-hopping in the Pacific had succeeded.
What doesn’t add up
Popular retellings often say the Patricia Lake model was built of pykrete. The accounts here say otherwise: a history of the project on a website devoted to the scientist Charles F. Goodeve says it was made from ice blocks, not pykrete, and the labourer’s account describes ice fused with a tar and wood-shavings mix. The bathtub and gunshot stories come from later recollections and vary in their details; Cabinet even places Jasper in Ontario.
The remains, however, are real. Archaeologist Susan Langley surveyed them underwater in 1985. Divers find refrigeration pipes, a standing wall and scattered equipment 12 to 40 metres down on a steep slope. On July 31, 1988, the Alberta Underwater Archaeology Society placed a cairn and bronze plaque near the wreck, which has since been defaced with graffiti.
Still open
Some of the best stories may have grown in the telling: the bathtub at Chequers and the ricocheting bullet come from later recollections that vary in their details. Even what the Patricia Lake model was made of gets retold: popular versions say pykrete, a project history says ice blocks, and one labourer remembered ice fused with a tar and wood-shavings mix. The men who cut that ice were told little about what they were building.
Where it stands (for now)
Declassified. The Allies did plan an aircraft carrier of ice, a large model was built and tested on Patricia Lake in 1943, and its remains are on the lake bed. Some of the livelier anecdotes may have grown in the telling, but the project itself is on the record.
Sources
-
Document
A Description of the Iceberg Aircraft Carrier and the Bearing of the Mechanical Properties of Frozen Wood Pulp Upon Some Problems of Glacier Flow
· Journal of Glaciology (M. F. Perutz)
“Pykrete, in fact, was ductile and could even be machined on a lathe.” - News The Floating Island: HMS Habbakuk and the icy promise of pykrete · Cabinet magazine (Paul Collins)
- News Code name: Habbakuk – ‘Most Secret’ · DIVER magazine · Nov. 11, 2012
- News War Ship, Ice Blocks and Mennonite COs (Mennonite Historian, September 2003) · Mennonite Historian
- Source The Patricia Lake Project: testing the Habakkuk concept · C. F. Goodeve family history site
More: the case files, every source behind every story.