Historical mysteries

Roanoke’s lost colony and ‘CROATOAN’: did the settlers simply move to Hatteras?

John White returned in 1590 to find ‘CROATOAN’ carved on a post and no distress sign; digs on Hatteras Island and inland have since turned up European objects, but nothing yet ties them firmly to the 1587 colonists.

RedactedReal facts underneath, and the theory fits them, but pieces are still blacked out.

Published Oct. 13, 2026Last checked Oct. 5, 2026

What’s claimed

In 1587, more than a hundred English men, women and children settled on Roanoke Island, in what is now North Carolina. When their governor, John White, came back three years later, they were gone. The National Park Service lists the main explanations offered since: a hurricane, famine and disease, a Spanish attack, or a move elsewhere. The theory examined here is the one the colonists themselves seem to have pointed to: that they went to Croatoan, today’s Hatteras Island, and lived among the Croatoan people. Researchers digging on Hatteras say they have now proved it.

What’s on the record

White sailed to England in 1587 for supplies, and the threat of the Spanish Armada kept English ships at home. He finally landed on Roanoke on August 18, 1590. He found the letters "CRO" carved on a tree and the word "CROATOAN" on a palisade post, with no signs of a struggle or a hasty departure; the houses had been taken down, not destroyed. According to White’s instructions, the colonists were to carve the name of their destination and add a cross beneath it if they left in distress. There was no cross. Croatoan was home to Manteo, a Croatoan man who had learned English and helped the English negotiate for land on Roanoke. White prepared to sail there, but a storm drove him back to England.

Two research groups have since gone looking. The First Colony Foundation followed a fort symbol hidden under a patch on one of White’s maps to a site in Bertie County, about 50 miles (80 km) inland, nicknamed Site X. There, a team led by archaeologist Nick Luccketti found about two dozen pieces of English pottery, which he argued showed that several colonists had lived there. On Hatteras, Mark Horton of the University of Bristol and volunteers from Scott Dawson’s Croatoan Archaeological Society have reported a rapier hilt, gun parts, a writing slate, glass they say predates 1600 and many later European objects. In May 2025 they announced hammerscale, the tiny flakes thrown off when iron is forged, in a layer they date to the late 1500s using animal teeth radiocarbon-dated at the University of California, Irvine. Dawson called it the "smoking gun" showing that Europeans were living there.

What doesn’t add up

Much of the Hatteras material is later than the colony. Horton himself has cautioned that some finds date to the middle or late 1600s and could be heirlooms or trade goods. A signet ring found in 1998 and once hailed as a link was later dated to the 17th century. East Carolina University archaeologist Charles Ewen has said he wants to see structures and European burials, and Luccketti has said he has seen no evidence of English people actually living at Croatoan. The park service’s summary is blunt: artifacts have been found, but no human remains, graves, buildings or village sites have been definitively linked to the Lost Colony. The 2025 hammerscale results were first announced through the press.

Still open

No human remains, graves, buildings or village sites have been definitively linked to the Lost Colony, the National Park Service says, and the two main digs point to different places: Site X inland and Hatteras on the coast. The 2025 hammerscale results were first announced through the press. A structure or a European burial from the 1580s on Hatteras, the kind of find Charles Ewen has asked for, would move this file.

Where it stands (for now)

Redacted. White’s own record points to Croatoan, he found no distress cross, and Hatteras has produced European objects, some possibly from the right decades. Nothing found yet ties firmly to the 1587 colonists, so a move to Croatoan, by some or all of them, fits the evidence without being proved.

Sources

  1. Document 1590 Voyage · National Park Service (Fort Raleigh National Historic Site)
  2. Document The Major Theories of the Lost Colony · National Park Service (Fort Raleigh National Historic Site)
  3. News Have We Found the “Lost Colony”? (Scott Dawson) · American Heritage
  4. News Newfound survivor camp may explain fate of the famed Lost Colony of Roanoke · National Geographic · Nov. 4, 2020
  5. News Back to Square One With Lost Colony? · Coastal Review · May 18, 2016
  6. News ‘Smoking gun’ evidence of Lost Colony’s relocation to Hatteras Island makes international news · Island Free Press · May 14, 2025

More: the case files, every source behind every story.

Talk about it

Start a thread on this story Know more? Send a tip