Rogue waves: the sailors’ ‘myth’ confirmed by the Draupner wave of New Year’s Day 1995
For centuries sailors told of walls of water from nowhere, and scientists doubted them. On January 1, 1995, a laser on the Draupner platform in the North Sea measured one at 25.6 metres.
What’s claimed
Rogue waves, also called freak or killer waves, are single waves far bigger than the sea around them that seem to come out of nowhere. For centuries mariners told of such walls of water swamping or breaking ships in otherwise ordinary storms, and for just as long the stories were treated as sailors’ yarns, at odds with what scientists knew about waves. The claim is that the sailors were right: that these waves are real, more common than the old models allowed, and behind the loss of ships.
What’s on the record
The turning point came on January 1, 1995, at the Draupner platform, a gas pipeline support complex in the Norwegian North Sea about 160 kilometres off the southern tip of Norway. A downward-pointing laser under the platform recorded a single wave 25.6 metres (84 feet) high, at a time when the significant wave height in the area was about 12 metres. The reading was confirmed by other sensors, the platform suffered only minor damage, and it became the first rogue wave ever measured by an instrument. NOAA now describes rogue waves as those more than twice the size of the waves around them, and notes that scientists have accepted them as real only in the past few decades.
Ships kept meeting them. In February 1995 the liner Queen Elizabeth 2 met a wave about 29 metres high in a North Atlantic hurricane; her captain, Ronald Warwick, said it looked as if they were heading into “the White Cliffs of Dover.” Within a single week in February and March 2001, two cruise ships, the Bremen and the Caledonian Star, had their bridge windows smashed by 30-metre waves in the South Atlantic, and the Bremen drifted without navigation or propulsion for two hours.
Then came a count. In December 2000 the European Union launched MaxWave, a three-year project led by Wolfgang Rosenthal of the GKSS research centre in Germany. Using about 30,000 radar images from the European Space Agency’s ERS satellites, covering just three weeks, the team found more than ten waves above 25 metres around the world. ESA reported in 2004 that severe weather had sunk more than 200 supertankers and container ships over 200 metres long in two decades, and that rogue waves were believed to be the major cause in many of those losses.
In 2019 researchers from the universities of Oxford and Edinburgh recreated a scaled-down Draupner wave in a laboratory tank, by crossing two groups of waves at about 120 degrees, and published the result in the Journal of Fluid Mechanics.
What doesn’t add up
Their existence is no longer in doubt. What is still argued is how they form. Ton van den Bremer, a fluid dynamicist and co-author of the 2019 study, told Quanta Magazine that two mechanisms compete to explain them: many waves simply lining up at one point, or nonlinear effects that let waves feed off one another. The second needs deep water, he said, and probably did not play a role at Draupner. Whether rogue waves can be forecast remains a research question.
Still open
Their existence is settled; how they form is not. Ton van den Bremer says two mechanisms compete, many waves lining up at one point or nonlinear effects that let waves feed off one another, and the second probably played no role at Draupner. Whether rogue waves can be forecast is still a research question. MaxWave’s count covered just three weeks of satellite images, a small window on a very big sea.
Where it stands (for now)
Declassified. Instruments, satellites and laboratory experiments have confirmed that rogue waves are real, starting with the laser reading at Draupner on New Year’s Day 1995. The sailors were right; what scientists still argue about is why the waves happen and whether they can be forecast.
Sources
- Document Ship-sinking monster waves revealed by ESA satellites · European Space Agency · July 20, 2004
- Document What is a rogue wave? · NOAA National Ocean Service
- News What Causes Giant Rogue Waves? · Quanta Magazine · June 13, 2023
- News Scientists Recreate 25-Year Old Freak Wave in a Laboratory for the First Time · Vice (Motherboard) · Jan. 21, 2019
- Source Draupner wave · Wikipedia
More: the case files, every source behind every story.