The Shakespeare authorship question: Oxford, Bacon, Marlowe and the Stratford record
Since the Victorian era, doubters have argued that the Earl of Oxford, Francis Bacon or Christopher Marlowe wrote Shakespeare’s plays; the surviving records point to the man from Stratford.
What’s claimed
The Shakespeare authorship question asks whether William Shakespeare of Stratford-upon-Avon, the actor who died in Stratford on April 23, 1616, really wrote the plays and poems published under his name. Doubters, often called anti-Stratfordians, ask how a man of modest origins and schooling could have had such insight into law, politics and court life, and argue that the true author hid behind his name. The leading candidates are Edward de Vere, 17th Earl of Oxford (the “Oxfordian” theory); the philosopher and statesman Francis Bacon (the “Baconian” theory); and the playwright Christopher Marlowe. Queen Elizabeth, the Earl of Derby and even King James have also been put forward.
What’s on the record
The doubts are fairly recent. The Shakespeare Birthplace Trust dates them to the Victorian period, more than 200 years after Shakespeare’s death, when an American writer, Delia Bacon, became convinced that Francis Bacon was the author. The Oxford theory came later: an English schoolmaster, J. Thomas Looney, proposed de Vere in his 1920 book “Shakespeare” Identified, History.com notes.
The case for the Stratford man rests on documents. In 1598 Francis Meres named Shakespeare in Palladis Tamia as a writer and listed his plays. The historian William Camden counted him among the great writers of the age. His fellow actors John Heminges and Henry Condell gathered his plays into the First Folio, published seven years after his death, and Ben Jonson’s tribute in that book calls him the “sweet swan of Avon,” the river that runs through Stratford. The Birthplace Trust also points to Stratford’s records and to his monument, with its bust and inscription, in Holy Trinity Church.
Newer finds point the same way. In 2017 the Folger Shakespeare Library described heraldic manuscripts from around 1602, traced by Heather Wolfe of the Folger, in which a herald attacking the coat of arms granted to Shakespeare’s father dismissed the son as a mere player. The Folger argues that these papers tie the London actor to the Stratford gentleman who held those arms.
Collaboration is a separate matter. In 2016 the New Oxford Shakespeare edition added Marlowe’s name beside Shakespeare’s on the title pages of the three Henry VI plays, the Folger reported. That is a question of co-writing, not of someone else writing everything.
What doesn’t add up
Each rival has a problem of timing. Marlowe was stabbed to death in 1593, as documents including a coroner’s report record, before most of the plays were written; Marlovians have to argue that the body the coroner saw was someone else’s, the biographer Charles Nicholl explained for the Birthplace Trust. Oxford died in 1604, yet some of Shakespeare’s later plays were published after that, History.com points out. Bacon’s backers face the same task as the others: explaining away the contemporaries who named Shakespeare as the writer.
The doubters are right about one thing: nothing has been found documenting the actual writing of the plays and sonnets. But the Birthplace Trust, which points to the contemporaries who named him, regards the matter as settled.
Still open
The doubters are right about one thing: nothing has been found documenting the actual writing of the plays and sonnets. How much was co-written is still being worked out; in 2016 the New Oxford Shakespeare put Marlowe’s name beside Shakespeare’s on the three Henry VI plays. A document tying a rival to the writing would move this file, and so, the other way, would more finds like the herald’s papers of around 1602.
Where it stands (for now)
Unconfirmed. The case for a hidden author rests on inference about what the writer must have known, not on documents. The surviving records, from Meres in 1598 to the First Folio, name Shakespeare, and two of the main rivals were dead before many of the plays appeared; the Birthplace Trust regards the matter as settled.
Sources
- Source The Shakespeare Authorship Question · Shakespeare Birthplace Trust
- Source Shakespeare’s Life: From the Folger Shakespeare Editions · Folger Shakespeare Library
- Source William Shakespeare, Poet and Gentleman · Folger Shakespeare Library (The Collation) · Jan. 17, 2017
- News Did Shakespeare Really Write His Own Plays? · History.com · July 14, 2015
- Source Marlowe and Shakespeare’s Authorship (Charles Nicholl) · Shakespeare Birthplace Trust (60 Minutes with Shakespeare)
- Source Shakespeare and Marlowe: Attributing ‘Henry VI’ Authorship · Folger Shakespeare Library (Shakespeare Unlimited) · Feb. 20, 2017
More: the case files, every source behind every story.