Historical mysteries

The Shroud of Turin: the 1988 carbon dating, a bishop’s 1389 memo and the challenges

Three laboratories dated the Shroud of Turin to 1260–1390 in 1988, matching 14th-century objections; defenders dispute the sample, and new studies keep arguing both ways.

Under ReviewSerious people argue both sides; the evidence cuts both ways, and the file stays open.

Published Oct. 19, 2026Last checked Oct. 11, 2026

What’s claimed

The Shroud of Turin, also called the Holy Shroud and, in its early history, the Shroud of Lirey, is a linen cloth bearing the faint image of a man who appears to have been crucified. It is in the care of the Archbishop of Turin, Italy, as its pontifical custodian. Many believers hold that it is the burial cloth of Jesus. Sceptics say it is a medieval work of art. The Catholic Church has no official position on whether it is authentic, EWTN News noted in 2026.

What’s on the record

The cloth enters history in 14th-century France. According to a 2025 summary from the publisher Taylor & Francis, it was displayed at Lirey, in Champagne, removed around 1355 after an inquiry found it was not authentic and that people had been paid to fake miracles, and shown again more than three decades later. In 1389 Pierre d’Arcis, Bishop of Troyes, sent a memorandum to Pope Clement VII declaring it a fake, said a predecessor had rejected it around 1355, and asked King Charles VI of France to stop the showings. In August 2025 the historian Nicolas Sarzeaud of UCLouvain published, in the Journal of Medieval History, an objection that may be even older: the theologian Nicole Oresme, writing most likely after 1370, cited the Lirey cloth as an example of fraud by clergy.

The scientific test came in 1988. On April 21 that year, small samples were cut from the cloth in the sacristy of Turin Cathedral. Laboratories in Arizona, Oxford and Zurich dated them by accelerator mass spectrometry, alongside three control samples of known age. Their 1989 paper in Nature gave a date of AD 1260 to 1390, with at least 95 per cent confidence, and called the results “conclusive evidence that the linen of the Shroud of Turin is mediaeval.”

What doesn’t add up

Defenders of the shroud have challenged that test ever since, and some challenges have reached peer-reviewed journals. The laboratories never published their raw data; in 2017, in response to a legal request, the British Museum released them. A 2019 statistical reanalysis in Archaeometry by T. Casabianca and colleagues concluded that the data strongly suggest homogeneity “is lacking,” and that the procedure should be reconsidered. In 2022, Liberato De Caro of Italy’s National Research Council used X-rays to measure the natural ageing of the flax cellulose in a sample of the linen and argued the cloth was about 2,000 years old, Catholic News Agency reported.

Sceptical research has not stopped either. In July 2025 Cicero Moraes, a Brazilian 3D designer, argued in Archaeometry that the image fits a cloth laid over a low-relief carving better than one laid over a human body. The International Center of Sindonology in Turin replied that the conclusion was not new and that his modelling software was not designed for scientific purposes. In 2026 a team including the geneticist Gianni Barcaccia of the University of Padua released, as a preprint, DNA analysis of material sampled from the cloth in 1978. It found traces from many regions, including the Mediterranean, India and North America, and signs of heavy handling over centuries; the researchers said DNA could not date the cloth.

Still open

The laboratories never published their raw data; it came out only in 2017, after a legal request to the British Museum, and a 2019 reanalysis said the data strongly suggest the samples were not homogeneous. De Caro’s 2022 X-ray dating has been argued over, and the 2026 DNA preprint says DNA cannot date the cloth at all. Neither has settled the question. Only further testing of the cloth itself is likely to.

Where it stands (for now)

Under Review. Radiocarbon dating by three laboratories and the objections of two 14th-century churchmen point to a medieval origin, and that remains the weight of the evidence. Peer-reviewed challenges to the 1988 sampling keep the question open for a number of researchers.

Sources

  1. Document Radiocarbon dating of the Shroud of Turin (Damon et al., Nature, 1989), full text · Nature, reproduced by Shroud.com
    “The results provide conclusive evidence that the linen of the Shroud of Turin is mediaeval.”
  2. Document Radiocarbon Dating of the Turin Shroud: New Evidence from Raw Data · Archaeometry (Wiley) · March 21, 2019
  3. News Was Jesus’ crucified body wrapped in the Shroud of Turin? A newly discovered Medieval document is the earliest written evidence to suggest not · Taylor & Francis Newsroom (Journal of Medieval History) · Aug. 27, 2025
  4. News Shroud of Turin center disputes new study that challenges authenticity of burial cloth · Catholic World Report (CNA) · Aug. 4, 2025
  5. News Is the Shroud of Turin merely a ‘work of art’? Years of study suggest otherwise · Catholic World Report (CNA) · Aug. 5, 2025
  6. News DNA research sheds new light on the Shroud of Turin’s complex history · Catholic World Report (EWTN News) · April 2, 2026

More: the case files, every source behind every story.

Talk about it

Start a thread on this story Know more? Send a tip