Secret societies & power

Skull and Bones: Yale’s 1832 secret society, the Bush–Kerry race and the power claims

Yale’s Skull and Bones has tapped 15 students a year since 1832 and counts three presidents among its members; the claim that it steers US power rests on networking, not proof.

UnconfirmedThin or second-hand evidence so far. Nobody has proven it, and nobody has closed it.

Published Oct. 23, 2026Last checked Oct. 11, 2026

What’s claimed

Skull and Bones, also known as the Order, Order 322 or simply Bones, is a senior society at Yale University in New Haven, Connecticut, founded in 1832. Its windowless clubhouse, the Tomb, and its famous alumni have made it a fixture of conspiracy writing. The claim is that Bones is far more than a club: that its members install one another in power, run or seed the CIA and Wall Street, and in some versions answer to the Illuminati.

What’s on the record

The society was founded in December 1832 by William Huntington Russell and Alphonso Taft. Each year it taps 15 students for their senior year, which, author Alexandra Robbins told CBS News, means roughly 800 members are living at any one time. Members meet in the Tomb on High Street and are forbidden to reveal what happens inside. Bones stayed all-male until women were admitted with the class of 1992, after a group of alumni went to court to stop the change.

The membership list is genuinely striking. It includes three US presidents, William Howard Taft, George H.W. Bush and George W. Bush, along with the publisher Henry Luce and the diplomat W. Averell Harriman. CBS reported in 2003 that George W. Bush had appointed five fellow Bonesmen to his administration. In 2004 both major presidential candidates, Bush and Senator John Kerry, were members. Asked about it on NBC’s Meet the Press, broadcast February 8, 2004, Bush replied: "It’s so secret we can’t talk about it." Kerry, interviewed separately, also declined to give details.

The society’s legends have even reached the courts. In 2009, 20 descendants of the Apache leader Geronimo sued in federal court in Washington, alleging that Bonesmen took some of his remains from his grave at Fort Sill, Oklahoma, in 1918; the rumour names Prescott Bush, grandfather of George W. Bush. A judge dismissed the case in July 2010 on legal grounds without ruling on the story itself, which NBC New York noted has been disputed for years.

What doesn’t add up

Robbins, who says she spoke with about 100 members for her book Secrets of the Tomb, argues that the society’s purpose is to place as many members as possible in positions of influence, and that it works as an unusually tight alumni network. But she told MSNBC that the truth sits in the middle ground between world conspiracy and harmless club, calling Bones "basically one huge superiority complex." Fifteen students a year from one of the world’s most elite universities will produce powerful people whether or not they share a secret. No document has shown Bones directing policy, controlling an agency or choosing a president. And the 2004 race cuts both ways: if the society picked the winner, it also fielded the loser.

Still open

What happens inside the Tomb is still known only to members, who are forbidden to reveal it, and both Bush and Kerry declined to say in 2004. The Geronimo story was never tested: the 2009 lawsuit was dismissed in 2010 on legal grounds, without any ruling on whether remains were taken from Fort Sill. Evidence of the society acting as a body to steer policy or appointments, rather than members helping members, would move this rating.

Where it stands (for now)

Unconfirmed. Skull and Bones is real, secretive and very well connected, and its members have helped one another’s careers. That it steers American power as an organization rests so far on its alumni list and its rituals; no document has shown it directing policy or choosing a president.

Sources

  1. News Skull And Bones · CBS News (60 Minutes) · Oct. 1, 2003
  2. News Pres. George W. Bush interview highlights (Meet the Press) · NBC News · Feb. 7, 2004
  3. News ‘Bonesmen’ for president · NBC News (MSNBC Countdown) · March 9, 2004
  4. News Geronimo’s Fam Can’t Sue Feds, Yale Over Skull & Bones: Judge · NBC New York · Aug. 9, 2010
  5. Source Skull and Bones · Wikipedia

More: the case files, every source behind every story.

Talk about it

Start a thread on this story Know more? Send a tip