The Smithsonian ‘giant skeletons’ cover-up: newspaper giants and the mound record
Online posts say the Smithsonian hid or destroyed the bones of a race of giants dug from America’s ancient mounds; its own 19th-century reports printed the measurements instead.
What’s claimed
The Smithsonian giant skeletons theory, sometimes called the Smithsonian giants cover-up, holds that 19th-century diggers found the bones of a lost race of giants in the burial mounds of the Ohio and Mississippi valleys, and that the Smithsonian Institution gathered up the evidence and then hid or destroyed it to protect the accepted story of America’s past. Believers point to old newspaper reports of huge skeletons and to measurements printed in the Smithsonian’s own publications. Versions circulating online since 2014 add that a court ruling forced the Smithsonian to confess to destroying thousands of giant skeletons. We could not retrieve that original article, but it is widely attributed to World News Daily Report, a Quebec-based website launched in 2013 whose disclaimer describes its articles as satire and its characters as fictional.
What’s on the record
The giants belong to a bigger 19th-century myth. Many Americans then believed that the great earthworks of the Ohio and Mississippi valleys had been built by a vanished people, imagined in various versions as Israelites, Vikings or Phoenicians, rather than by the ancestors of Native Americans, the writer Robert Silverberg explained in American Heritage in 1969. Newspapers fed the idea. Jason Colavito, who has collected the accounts giant-believers cite, notes that stories of giant bones became markedly more frequent after the Cardiff Giant hoax of 1869, and that there is little confirmation any of them is true. They include an 1845 Tennessee report of a skeleton 18 feet long, later identified as a young mastodon, and an 1883 Missouri report of a human 12 feet tall.
The Smithsonian is the institution that took the lost-race myth apart. In late 1881 John Wesley Powell, head of the Smithsonian’s Bureau of Ethnology, chose Cyrus Thomas to lead a Congress-funded investigation of the mounds. Thomas started out believing in a separate race of Mound Builders, Silverberg wrote, but his fieldwork, which turned up European-made trade goods in some mounds, changed his mind. His 1894 report, published as the bureau’s twelfth annual report, concluded that the mounds were built by several distinct peoples, the ancestors of known Indigenous nations.
The bureau’s reports did record some very tall individuals. Colavito quotes the 1894 report on a burial in a mound in Roane County, Tennessee, where the skeleton measured 7 feet 3 inches from the base of the skull to the toes, and the report estimated the person had been “fully 7½ feet high” in life. An 1887 bureau report described a skeleton of 7 to 8 feet from a mound in Illinois.
What doesn’t add up
Those passages work against the cover-up story. The Smithsonian printed them in its own official reports, which have been public for well over a century, and they describe unusually tall individuals, not a race of giants. Colavito presents such measurements as likely errors. The 12-foot giants and their like, by contrast, come from newspapers, not from bones anyone can examine; Colavito also warns that fringe authors have often selectively edited the old texts. As for the satirical website, Snopes has described World News Daily Report as having a long record of entirely fabricated stories.
Still open
The 12-foot giants live only in newspaper columns: no bones anyone can examine have been traced from those reports, and Colavito notes there is little confirmation any of them is true. We could not retrieve the original “court ruling” article, though it is widely attributed to a site that calls its own work satire. A skeleton from one of those stories, turning up in a collection and measured again, would reopen this file.
Where it stands (for now)
Tinfoil. The Smithsonian’s own surveys published the tallest skeletons its excavators recorded, about seven and a half feet in the best-known case, and concluded that Native peoples built the mounds. The best-known “admission” of a cover-up traces to a satire site, and no giant bones have surfaced so far.
Sources
- News …and The Mound-builders Vanished From The Earth (Robert Silverberg) · American Heritage
- Source Smithsonian Giant Reports · Jason Colavito
- Source Newspaper Accounts of Giants · Jason Colavito
- Source World News Daily Report · Wikipedia
More: the case files, every source behind every story.