The Somerton Man: the Tamam Shud case, the Rubaiyat code and the Carl Webb DNA match
A man found dead on an Adelaide beach in 1948 carried a scrap reading Tamam Shud. In 2022 researchers named him Carl Webb from DNA; authorities have yet to confirm it. The spy theory lacks evidence.
What’s claimed
The Tamam Shud case, also known as the Somerton Man mystery (and often misspelled Taman Shud), began on December 1, 1948, when a man in a suit was found dead on Somerton Beach in Adelaide, South Australia. He carried no identification, the maker’s labels had been snipped from almost all of his clothes, and a tiny scrap of paper in his fob pocket read “Tamam Shud,” Persian for “it is finished.” Two claims grew from the case: that he was a Cold War spy, and, much more recently, that he has finally been identified as a Melbourne engineer named Carl “Charles” Webb.
What’s on the record
Doctors suspected poison, but repeated tests found none, and no cause of death was ever established. At the inquest, opened by coroner Thomas Erskine Cleland on June 17, 1949, the pharmacologist Cedric Stanton Hicks suggested a rare poison that would leave no trace. The scrap was traced to a copy of the Rubaiyat of Omar Khayyam, in Edward FitzGerald’s translation, which a man handed in to police in July 1949, saying he had found it in a car near the beach. Scribbled inside was what looked like a code, and a phone number that led to a local nursing student, Jessica “Jo” Thomson. She denied knowing the dead man but named a man she had once given a Rubaiyat, Alfred Boxall. Boxall turned out to be alive, with his copy intact.
Decades of theories followed, from a jilted lover to a ballet dancer to a Soviet agent. On May 19, 2021, South Australia Police exhumed the body from Adelaide’s West Terrace Cemetery for DNA testing.
On July 26, 2022, University of Adelaide professor Derek Abbott, working with the US genealogist Colleen Fitzpatrick, announced that DNA from hairs caught in a plaster bust of the man pointed to Carl Webb, born in Footscray, Victoria, on November 16, 1905: an electrical engineer and instrument maker with no recorded death. They built a family tree of about 4,000 people and found cousins on both sides of his family through consumer genealogy databases. Webb had married Dorothy Robertson in 1941; she later moved to South Australia, and in October 1951 she published notice of divorce proceedings on the ground of desertion. Abbott said he was 99.9 per cent confident.
What doesn’t add up
The identification has not been officially confirmed. In 2022, SA Police and Forensic Science SA said they had not verified Abbott’s findings and would comment once results from their own testing came in. In its February 2025 update, Smithsonian Magazine reported that authorities had yet to verify the result using DNA from the exhumed remains, though a police spokesperson had called them cautiously optimistic. Even if the name holds, it does not explain how he died, why his labels were gone or what the letters in the book mean. The spy theory rests on those oddities and the Cold War timing; none of the sources here offers evidence that he worked for any intelligence service.
Still open
Authorities have not confirmed the Carl Webb identification: as of Smithsonian’s February 2025 update, they had yet to verify it with DNA from the exhumed remains, though police called themselves cautiously optimistic. Even if the name holds, no cause of death was ever established, nobody has explained why his labels were gone, and what the letters scribbled in the Rubaiyat mean is still unknown. No source offers evidence that he worked for any intelligence service.
Where it stands (for now)
Redacted. The DNA and genealogy behind the Carl Webb identification are detailed and widely reported, but police and the coroner have not yet confirmed it. The separate claim that the Somerton Man was a spy has nothing behind it so far but the mystery itself.
Sources
- News Somerton Man identified as Melbourne electrical engineer, researcher says · ABC News (Australia) · July 25, 2022
- News The Somerton Man has been named. What do we know about Carl ‘Charles’ Webb? · ABC News (Australia) · Aug. 1, 2022
- News Australia’s Somerton man mystery ‘solved’ as DNA points to man’s identity, professor claims · CNN · July 25, 2022
- News Somerton man: Body exhumed in bid to solve Australian mystery · BBC News · May 18, 2021
- News The Enduring Mystery of the Somerton Man, One of Australia’s Most Puzzling Cold Cases · Smithsonian Magazine · Feb. 18, 2025
More: the case files, every source behind every story.