Stanley Meyer’s water fuel cell: the “water-powered car” and the poisoning rumour
An Ohio judge found Stanley Meyer’s water-car business guilty of fraud in 1996; his 1998 death was ruled an aneurysm, yet claims persist he was poisoned to bury the invention.
What’s claimed
Stanley Meyer, an inventor from Grove City, Ohio, said he had built a car that ran on water. His "water fuel cell", sometimes called the Meyer cell, was said to split ordinary water into hydrogen and oxygen using far less electricity than standard chemistry allows, then burn the hydrogen in an engine fitted with special injectors in place of spark plugs. On Columbus television he showed off a dune buggy and said 22 US gallons of water would carry it from Los Angeles to New York. Supporters say the invention was suppressed, and that Meyer, who died suddenly in March 1998, was poisoned to stop it. A 2021 Facebook post went further and said the Pentagon killed him.
What’s on the record
Meyer sold investors "dealerships", the right to do business in Water Fuel Cell technology. Two of them sued. On September 3, 1996, Judge William Corzine III of the Fayette County Common Pleas Court in Ohio found that Meyer’s company had committed "gross and egregious fraud", Lead Stories reported, and Meyer was ordered to repay the investors. Accounts of the case, drawing on a December 1996 report in The Sunday Times, say expert witnesses who examined the cell found nothing revolutionary in it, only conventional electrolysis, and that the repayment came to $25,000.
Meyer died on March 20, 1998, aged 57, after a meal with prospective investors at a restaurant in Ohio. His brother said Meyer ran outside saying he had been poisoned. The Franklin County coroner recorded a ruptured cerebral artery aneurysm and noted his high blood pressure, and Grove City police found no evidence of foul play, PolitiFact and Lead Stories reported. Lead Stories cited a 2007 Columbus Dispatch account that the only drugs detected were lidocaine, a pain reliever, and phenytoin, a seizure medicine. A Pentagon spokesperson told PolitiFact the department had no information on Meyer or his death.
His patents have since expired and are in the public domain. Anyone may read them and build the cell, yet no engine or vehicle maker has adopted the design.
What doesn’t add up
The physics, first. Water is what is left after hydrogen has already burned. Splitting it back into hydrogen and oxygen takes more energy than burning that hydrogen returns, so a car that made its own fuel from water would be creating energy from nothing, which would break the first law of thermodynamics. Science Feedback, reviewing a similar video in 2021, concluded such a car cannot run solely on water. Hua Zhao, dean of engineering at Brunel University London, told AFP in 2019 that breaking the bonds in water will always take more energy than the engine can supply, PolitiFact reported.
The suppression story has its own problem: there is nothing hidden to suppress. The patents are public. As for the poisoning, the remark that started it came from Meyer himself in his last minutes, and the coroner, the toxicology and the police all pointed to natural causes. The fraud ruling came 18 months before his death, from a court in his own state, after experts looked at the device.
Still open
The only account of Meyer’s last words comes from his brother, and the official findings, from the coroner, the toxicology and the Grove City police, all pointed to natural causes. What the court’s expert witnesses found is known mostly second-hand, from accounts drawing on a 1996 Sunday Times report. The patents are public, so anyone can still build the cell; so far no engine or vehicle maker has adopted it.
Where it stands (for now)
Tinfoil. An Ohio court found the business committed fraud, physicists say a car cannot run on water alone, and the coroner and police recorded an aneurysm and found no foul play. What is documented is the lawsuit, the sudden death and the rumour that grew around it.
Sources
- News Fact Check: ‘Water Car Inventor’ Stanley Meyer Was NOT Killed By Pentagon — Cause Of Death Was A Brain Aneurysm · Lead Stories · June 2, 2021
- News No, Stanley Meyer was not assassinated by the Pentagon · PolitiFact · June 2, 2021
- News Claim of water-fueled dune buggy defies physics · PolitiFact · Aug. 30, 2022
- News A “water-powered” car still requires other forms of fuel to work; it cannot run solely on water, contrary to viral Facebook video claims · Science Feedback · March 14, 2021
- Source Water fuel cell · Wikipedia
More: the case files, every source behind every story.