The Dendera ‘light bulbs’: electric lamps or a creation myth carved in a temple crypt?
Reliefs in the Hathor temple at Dendera are said to show ancient electric lamps; the hieroglyphs carved beside them describe gold cult statues of the serpent god Harsomtus rising from a lotus.
What’s claimed
In the temple of the goddess Hathor at Dendera, in Upper Egypt, a few carved scenes show a large bulb-shaped object with a wavy snake stretched inside it, rising from a flower and propped up by a pillar with arms. Since the late 1980s, some writers have argued that these scenes record ancient electric lighting. Erich von Däniken described the relief as a lamp in a 1989 book, and the Austrian authors Krassa and Habeck built a full theory on it, after a Norwegian electrical engineer suggested the object could work as a lamp and an Austrian colleague built a working model. In their reading the snake is an electric discharge, the flower a lamp socket, its stem a cable and the pillar an insulator. Supporters add that electric light would explain a supposed lack of soot in Egyptian tombs.
What’s on the record
The temple is late by Egyptian standards. According to UNESCO, construction began in 54 BCE under Ptolemy XII Auletes, and the temple was completed under the Roman emperor Tiberius some 185 years after work started.
The "light" scenes are three objects, each shown twice: once in one of the temple’s southern crypts and once in a room of the temple itself. The crypts were treated as an image of the underworld. Their reliefs depict the cult statues once kept there, made of precious materials and later looted or destroyed, which were stored underground as the bodies of the gods and brought up to the temple roof to be renewed by sunlight.
Each scene has a caption, and the captions read like an inventory. They name the figure as Harsomtus, a god shown as an upright snake emerging from a lotus flower, usually mounted on a sacred boat. The bulb is an oval container called hn, which may stand for the womb of the sky goddess Nut. The texts give materials and sizes: gold, metal or precious stones, three or four palms high, or a cubit. One caption reads: "Harsomtus in the hn-container of the Mesketet-night-barge." The scene fits a creation story in which the sun rises from a lotus.
What doesn’t add up
Nothing physical backs the lamp reading. The archaeologist Kenneth Feder has argued that if Egyptians had such lamps, remains such as glass, sockets or filaments should have turned up in excavations; the sceptic Frank Dörnenburg notes that more than 200 years of digging in Egypt have produced no generators. The soot argument fails on its own terms: Dörnenburg photographed soot on the very crypt walls that carry the reliefs, found soot in many pyramids and tombs, and noted that ancient records from the Valley of the Kings list wicks and lamp oil issued to tomb workers. An olive-oil lamp with a short wick, he found by experiment, burns with very little smoke. And there is no power source: Dörnenburg calculated that the so-called Baghdad batteries, found far from Egypt and later in date, would have needed about forty cells to light a single one-watt bulb.
Still open
The cult statues the reliefs depict were made of gold, metal or precious stones, and they are gone, looted or destroyed; we know them only from the carvings and their captions. The lamp reading has a simple test it has not passed: glass, sockets, filaments or a generator turning up in an excavation. In more than 200 years of digging in Egypt, none has.
Where it stands (for now)
Tinfoil. The reliefs are real and look odd to modern eyes, but the hieroglyphs beside them say what they show: gold cult statues of a serpent god rising from a lotus. No wire, glass or generator for an ancient lamp has been found so far.
Sources
- Source Dendera light · Wikipedia
-
Document
Pharaonic temples in Upper Egypt from the Ptolemaic and Roman periods
· UNESCO World Heritage Centre
“The construction of the temple of Hathor started in 54 BC in the reign of Ptolemy Auletes.” - Source Dendera Light · Atlas Obscura
- Source Lights of the Pharaohs: the Electric Lights in Egypt? (guest article by Frank Dörnenburg) · World Mysteries · Jan. 29, 2012
More: the case files, every source behind every story.