Historical mysteries

The Franklin Expedition: lead, Inuit testimony and the wrecks of Erebus and Terror

For more than a century, Inuit accounts of how Franklin’s men died were doubted or dismissed; Inuit knowledge then helped find both ships, while the old lead-poisoning theory has lost ground.

DeclassifiedThey admitted it, on paper: official files, admissions or solid evidence. What else is still in the drawer?

Published Oct. 19, 2026Last checked Oct. 5, 2026

What’s claimed

Sir John Franklin sailed from England in 1845 with HMS Erebus and HMS Terror to chart the Northwest Passage, and none of the 129 officers and men came home. Two explanations have long competed. One holds that the expedition was poisoned by its own supplies: lead from the solder of thousands of food tins. The other, resisted for decades in Britain, is what Inuit told searchers from the 1850s on: that the crews left their ships, starved as they walked south, and that some resorted to cannibalism.

What’s on the record

The expedition’s best-known written record is a note left in a cairn at Victory Point on King William Island and found in 1859 by Lt. William Hobson of Francis McClintock’s search. Its first message, from May 1847, reported all well. A second, added in April 1848 and signed by Captains Francis Crozier and James Fitzjames, said that Franklin had died on June 11, 1847, that nine officers and 15 men were dead, and that 105 survivors had left the ice-bound ships for the Back River.

Inuit had already described the ending. In 1854, John Rae heard Inuit accounts of starving white men seen four years earlier, including reports of cannibalism, and brought back silverware and Franklin’s own medal. According to Parks Canada, Lady Franklin condemned Rae, and Charles Dickens used his journal Household Words to insist that British officers would never resort to cannibalism and to accuse Inuit of killing the men. From 1860 to 1871, the American Charles Francis Hall gathered Inuit testimony, including from Inukpujijuq, who described visiting a ship as a child and placed it south of King William Island.

Those accounts have been borne out. In 1997, the late Dr. Anne Keenleyside found cut marks on nearly a quarter of the human bones at one King William Island site, showing that the bodies of at least four men there had been subject to cannibalism. In September 2024, researchers from the University of Waterloo and Lakehead University used a living descendant’s DNA to identify a jawbone from that site as Fitzjames’s. It bears cut marks too.

Canada designated the still-missing wrecks a national historic site in 1992, and Parks Canada began a new series of searches in 2008, drawing on Inuit knowledge. Erebus was found on September 2, 2014, in the area Inukpujijuq had identified. Terror was found on September 3, 2016, after Sammy Kogvik of Gjoa Haven, a day into his time aboard the Arctic Research Foundation’s ship Martin Bergmann, mentioned seeing a large piece of wood sticking up through the ice in Terror Bay years earlier. Parks Canada confirmed the wreck’s identity on September 18.

What doesn’t add up

The lead theory has weakened. It grew from work in the 1980s by Owen Beattie’s team, who found high lead levels in remains from King William Island and in three sailors buried on Beechey Island during the first winter; the tins became the leading suspect. In 2018, a team led by Treena Swanston used synchrotron X-ray imaging to map lead in crew members’ bones and teeth and compared them with Royal Navy sailors buried in Antigua between 1793 and 1822. The Franklin men showed no unusually high exposure for the period, and much of their lead appears to have been absorbed before the voyage. The results, the authors wrote, "do not support the conclusion that Pb played a pivotal role in the loss of Franklin and his crew."

Still open

The last written word from the expedition is the April 1848 note at Victory Point; what happened to the 105 men who set out for the Back River is known mostly from Inuit testimony and from bones. The 2024 identification of Fitzjames used a living descendant’s DNA, which leaves room for more names to come the same way. How much lead mattered has been scaled back, not settled: the 2018 study found ordinary levels, much of it absorbed before the voyage.

Where it stands (for now)

Declassified. The Inuit accounts that Victorian Britain dismissed, of a desperate retreat, cannibalism and a ship south of King William Island, have been borne out by archaeology, DNA and the wrecks themselves. Lead poisoning is the weaker explanation today: the 2018 study found the crews’ lead levels ordinary for the Royal Navy of their time.

Sources

  1. Document Searching for Franklin - Wrecks of HMS Erebus and HMS Terror National Historic Site · Parks Canada
  2. Document Finding HMS Erebus - Wrecks of HMS Erebus and HMS Terror National Historic Site · Parks Canada
    “HMS Erebus was found on September 2, 2014.”
  3. Document Finding HMS Terror - Wrecks of HMS Erebus and HMS Terror National Historic Site · Parks Canada
    “On September 18, Parks Canada confirmed the wreck was the missing HMS Terror.”
  4. Document Franklin expedition lead exposure: New insights from high resolution confocal x-ray fluorescence imaging of skeletal microstructure · PLOS ONE · Aug. 22, 2018
    “Taken all together our skeletal microstructural results do not support the conclusion that Pb played a pivotal role in the loss of Franklin and his crew.”
  5. News Another Franklin expedition crew member has been identified · University of Waterloo · Sept. 23, 2024

More: the case files, every source behind every story.

Talk about it

Start a thread on this story Know more? Send a tip