The ‘lost cosmonauts’: rumours of Soviet spacemen who died before Gagarin
For decades, news-agency reports and amateur radio recordings suggested the Soviet Union hid cosmonauts who died in space; the one hidden cosmonaut death later confirmed happened on the ground.
What’s claimed
Before Yuri Gagarin became the first person in space on April 12, 1961, the story goes, other Soviet cosmonauts had already flown and died, and Moscow erased them from history. The best-known evidence is a set of recordings released in the 1960s by Achille and Giovanni Battista Judica-Cordiglia, Italian brothers who ran an amateur listening station called Torre Bert near Turin. They said they had picked up transmissions from doomed Soviet spacecraft, including, by their account, a woman cosmonaut dying on re-entry in November 1963. One message, as quoted from their recordings, says "we are going slower … the world will never know about us."
What’s on the record
The rumours are older than Gagarin’s flight. In 1959, the rocket pioneer Hermann Oberth claimed a pilot had been killed on a sub-orbital flight, and that December the Italian news agency Continentale named several supposed dead cosmonauts. In 1963, after a New York newspaper listed a group of Soviet high-altitude parachutists among the lost cosmonauts, the Soviet papers Izvestia and Krasnaya Zvezda published testimony and photographs of the men, alive. Russian journalist Yaroslav Golovanov later interviewed one of them, Alexey Belokonov, who confirmed that none had flown in space.
The Soviet Union did hide a death. On March 23, 1961, 20 days before Gagarin’s flight, trainee cosmonaut Valentin Bondarenko, 24, was fatally burned when an alcohol-soaked cotton pad he discarded landed on a hot plate in the oxygen-rich atmosphere of a pressure chamber. Izvestia acknowledged his death only in April 1986, 25 years later, UPI reported at the time. Another trainee, Grigoriy Nelyubov, dismissed in 1961 after a fight with soldiers at a rail station, was airbrushed out of an official group photograph; his identity also came out in 1986.
What doesn’t add up
The deaths in space have never been confirmed. Space historian James Oberg looked into a dozen rumoured cosmonaut deaths going back to 1957 and found nothing to support them; he said the Italian reports did not match any known accident. Critics have also questioned what Torre Bert could have heard. Aerospaceweb notes that its main antenna had to be turned by hand to follow spacecraft that cross the sky in minutes, and that biomedical data sent by radio would have sounded like nothing but static over an audio channel. Since the Soviet Union fell, disclosures have confirmed real disasters, but none that match the brothers’ accounts, IFLScience reported.
Still open
The Torre Bert recordings have never been verified, and critics question what the brothers’ equipment could have picked up at all. James Oberg found nothing to support a dozen rumoured deaths, and disclosures since 1991 have confirmed real disasters but none matching the brothers’ accounts. The Soviet Union kept Bondarenko’s death quiet for 25 years, so the honest open question is whether any other files from that era are still unopened.
Where it stands (for now)
Unconfirmed. It leans toward Tinfoil: Soviet secrecy was real and hid at least one cosmonaut death, which is why the rumour lasts. But the deaths in space rest on unverified recordings and second-hand reports, the named victims who were traced turned out to be alive, and nothing released since 1991 supports the rest so far.
Sources
- News Soviet cosmonaut death reported 25 years later · UPI Archives · April 3, 1986
- News Are there really “lost cosmonauts” stranded in space? · The Straight Dope
- Source Ask Us: Lost Cosmonaut Rumors · Aerospaceweb.org · July 2, 2005
- News The "Lost Cosmonauts" Theory And The Recording That Claims To Back It Up · IFLScience · May 31, 2022
- Document Remembering Yuri Gagarin 50 Years Later · NASA · March 26, 2018
- Source Lost Cosmonauts · Wikipedia
More: the case files, every source behind every story.