The Nimitz ‘Tic Tac’: the 2004 Navy encounter the Pentagon labelled unidentified
Navy pilots chased a white, wingless object off California in 2004, and the Pentagon later authenticated three Navy videos, but what the objects were remains officially unknown.
What’s claimed
On November 14, 2004, US Navy pilots training with the USS Nimitz carrier strike group off Southern California encountered an object they could not identify. They say it accelerated so fast it seemed to vanish. That encounter, nicknamed the "Tic Tac" after the object’s shape, and two infrared videos recorded by Navy aircrew in 2015, have become the core of the argument that unidentified craft operate in US military airspace. Some take it further and suggest a non-human origin.
What’s on the record
According to accounts given to CBS’s 60 Minutes in 2021, Cmdr. David Fravor, who commanded an F/A-18F squadron aboard the Nimitz, and Lt. Cmdr. Alex Dietrich were flying about 100 miles southwest of San Diego when they were diverted to investigate an unknown contact. Controllers on the USS Princeton, a ship in their training group, later told them they had been tracking similar objects for days. Each jet carried a weapons systems officer, making four aircrew witnesses.
The pilots said they saw a patch of churning water and, above it, a white object roughly the size of an F/A-18F, with no wings, markings or visible exhaust. Fravor said that when he tried to cut it off, it accelerated out of sight, and the Princeton picked it up again about 60 miles away. Later, another crew’s targeting camera recorded infrared video of what they believed was the same object. Fravor testified about the encounter before a House Oversight subcommittee on July 26, 2023.
On April 27, 2020, the Department of Defense formally released three unclassified Navy videos, one from November 2004 and two from January 2015. It noted they had already circulated after unauthorized releases in 2007 and 2017 and that the Navy had previously confirmed they were genuine. The phenomena in them, the department said, "remain characterized as ‘unidentified.’" The clips sit in the Naval Air Systems Command’s FOIA reading room under the file names FLIR, GIMBAL and GOFAST; the 2004 clip is widely known as FLIR1.
What doesn’t add up
The record establishes that the encounter happened and that the videos are authentic. It does not establish what the objects were. The most dramatic performance claims rest on the recollections of the people involved. The 2020 release consisted of the three videos; the Princeton radar data the aircrew describe was not part of it.
The videos have also proved less conclusive than they first appeared. In September 2023, NASA’s independent UAP study team worked through the on-screen numbers in GOFAST and calculated that the object was at about 13,000 feet (roughly 4,000 metres), not skimming the ocean, and moving at around 40 mph, which the team called "a typical wind speed at 13,000 feet." It said the impression of speed came at least partly from the jet’s own motion and parallax. The Pentagon’s All-domain Anomaly Resolution Office (AARO) has since published a case resolution that likewise places the GOFAST object about 13,000 feet above the Atlantic. At the time of writing, AARO’s case-resolution page lists no resolution for FLIR1 or GIMBAL.
Still open
The Princeton radar data that started the chase was not part of the 2020 release, and the most dramatic performance claims rest on the aircrew’s recollections. AARO has published a resolution for GOFAST but, at the time of writing, none for FLIR1 or GIMBAL. Release of the ship’s radar tracks, or an AARO finding on the 2004 clip, would move this file.
Where it stands (for now)
Declassified. The encounter, the witnesses and the videos are acknowledged in official statements, and the Pentagon called the objects unidentified when it released them. The rating covers the event, not any explanation: NASA and AARO have put a mundane reading on GOFAST, and the other two remain officially open.
Sources
-
Document
Statement by the Department of Defense on the Release of Historical Navy Videos
· U.S. Department of Defense (now war.gov) · April 26, 2020
“The aerial phenomena observed in the videos remain characterized as "unidentified."” - Video Documents | NAVAIR - FOIA · Naval Air Systems Command
-
News
Navy pilots recall "unsettling" 2004 UAP sighting
· CBS News (60 Minutes) · Aug. 28, 2021
“Seconds later, the USS Princeton reacquired the UAP on its radar. It was approximately 60 miles away.” - News The story behind the "Tic Tac" UFO sighting by Navy pilots in 2004 · CBS News · July 25, 2023
-
Document
Unidentified Anomalous Phenomena Independent Study Team Report
· NASA · Sept. 13, 2023
“This is a typical wind speed at 13,000 feet.” -
Document
AARO UAP Case Resolution Reports
· All-domain Anomaly Resolution Office (AARO)
“In January 2015, a U.S. Navy F/A-18F pilot recorded an object using a Forward Looking Infrared (FLIR) sensor about 13,000 feet above the Atlantic Ocean off the coast of Florida.”
More: the case files, every source behind every story.