The ‘non-human bodies’ shown to Mexico’s Congress in 2023: what the tests say
In September 2023 a Mexican journalist showed lawmakers two small, three-fingered bodies he said were non-human beings from Peru; scientists, the university he cited and Peruvian forensic experts have rejected the claim.
What’s claimed
On September 12, 2023, at a hearing on unidentified phenomena in Mexico’s Chamber of Deputies, journalist and ufologist Jaime Maussan had two small caskets opened in front of lawmakers. Inside were two dried bodies with large heads and three fingers on each hand. Speaking under oath, Maussan said they were non-human, found in Peru in 2017, about 1,000 years old, and carbon-dated by Mexico’s National Autonomous University (UNAM). He said one had been pregnant. A forensic doctor, José de Jesús Zalce Benítez, walked members through scans that he said showed large brains and no teeth.
What’s on the record
The hearing happened and the bodies were shown; the rejection came quickly. Ryan Graves, a former US Navy pilot who had testified at the same hearing about pilot sightings, wrote the next day that he was "deeply disappointed by this unsubstantiated stunt." Julieta Fierro, a researcher at UNAM’s Institute of Astronomy, said the university had never endorsed Maussan’s conclusions and that the claims made no sense. On September 13, UNAM’s Institute of Physics reissued a statement from 2017: its laboratory had carbon-dated small samples that year under a commercial agreement, such tests only estimate a sample’s age, and the lab draws no conclusions about where a sample came from.
Peru had dealt with similar specimens before. A 2017 report by Peru’s prosecutor’s office described earlier alleged alien bodies promoted by Maussan as recently manufactured dolls, covered with paper and synthetic glue to imitate skin. Wired reported that Peruvian specialists consider the small figures to be assemblages of human and animal bones, and that the World Committee on Mummy Studies has called the Nazca "mummies" a fraud.
Maussan returned to Congress in November 2023 with doctors who said the bodies had been living organisms. He acknowledged that none of the scientists said the results proved the bodies were extraterrestrial, adding that he went further himself, Reuters reported. In October 2023 Peruvian customs agents in Lima seized two doll-like figures in a package bound for a Mexican citizen. On January 12, 2024, forensic archaeologist Flavio Estrada, working for Peru’s prosecutor’s office, presented the results: "they are dolls assembled with bones of animals from this planet, with modern synthetic glues."
The other side
Maussan has continued to defend the bodies, saying in November 2023 that more than 30 per cent of their DNA is unknown. The Peruvian experts did not say the seized figures were the ones shown in Mexico, though they stressed that the remains shown in Mexico are not extraterrestrial either. None of the coverage reviewed for this story cites a peer-reviewed study that supports a non-human origin. Maussan’s earlier finds have not held up: in 2015 he presented a supposed alien child that was later identified as a mummified human child.
Still open
Maussan says more than 30 per cent of the bodies’ DNA is unknown, but none of the coverage reviewed cites a peer-reviewed study supporting a non-human origin. The Peruvian experts did not say the figures seized in Lima were the ones shown in Mexico, so the bodies presented to Congress have not been publicly matched to any forensic finding. An independent, published examination of those two bodies would say more than any hearing has.
Where it stands (for now)
Tinfoil. The hearing is real, but support for a non-human origin comes so far only from the people presenting the bodies. UNAM says its dating drew no such conclusion, and forensic specialists who examined similar figures in Peru found modern dolls of Earthly bones and synthetic glue.
Sources
- News A ufologist claims to show 2 alien corpses to Mexico’s Congress · NPR · Sept. 12, 2023
- News Experts pan ‘alien corpses’ shown to Mexican Congress, calling it a stunt · Global News · Sept. 14, 2023
- News No, This Is Not an Alien. Here’s Why · WIRED · Sept. 13, 2023
- News "Aliens" found in Peru are actually dolls made of bones, forensic experts declare · CBS News · Jan. 11, 2024
-
News
‘Totally made up story’: Mystery of Peru ‘alien’ corpses finally solved
· Global News · Jan. 14, 2024
“they are dolls assembled with bones of animals from this planet, with modern synthetic glues, therefore they were not assembled during pre-Hispanic times”
More: the case files, every source behind every story.