Secret technology

The Phoebus cartel: how 1920s bulb makers agreed to shorten the light bulb’s life

In 1924 the world’s biggest lamp makers formed a cartel that set household bulb life at 1,000 hours and fined factories whose bulbs lasted too long; there was a real efficiency argument, but also a profit motive.

DeclassifiedThey admitted it, on paper: official files, admissions or solid evidence. What else is still in the drawer?

Published Oct. 19, 2026Last checked Oct. 5, 2026

What’s claimed

The Phoebus cartel is the favourite example of planned obsolescence, the idea that manufacturers design products to fail so that customers have to buy them again. In its strongest form, the claim is that light bulbs could have lasted for decades, and that the industry conspired to make sure they didn’t.

What’s on the record

On December 23, 1924, representatives of the leading lamp makers met in Geneva and founded the cartel, according to Markus Krajewski, a media studies professor at the University of Basel, writing in IEEE Spectrum in 2014. Members included Osram of Germany, Philips of the Netherlands, Tungsram of Hungary, Britain’s Associated Electrical Industries, France’s Compagnie des Lampes and Japan’s Tokyo Electric. America’s General Electric was not itself a member but took part through its overseas subsidiaries. The cartel divided the world market into zones, each with production quotas.

By early 1925 members had codified a standard life of 1,000 hours for a household bulb, down from the 1,500 to 2,000 hours that Krajewski says had been common. Factories sent sample bulbs to a central laboratory in Switzerland, and a factory whose bulbs lasted longer or shorter than the standard paid a fine. Citing a graph held in the Berlin state archive, Krajewski reports that the average life of the cartel’s reference bulbs fell from 1,800 hours in 1926 to 1,205 hours in fiscal 1933–34. In 1927 Tokyo Electric wrote to the cartel that its sales had jumped fivefold after it shortened the life of its bulbs, and protested that this success should bring a heavy penalty. The 1924 agreement was meant to run until 1955; Krajewski writes that it was nullified in 1940, when the Second World War made coordination impossible.

In the United States, the government’s antitrust case against General Electric ended in a 1949 ruling. A 1980 staff report from the Federal Trade Commission summarized it: GE’s American parent stayed aloof from Phoebus, but cartel members did not sell lamps in the United States and Canada, where GE dominated, and the court found that the cartel and GE’s patent agreements with it had restricted competition in the United States.

The other side

There is a genuine engineering trade-off. A bulb designed to give more light for each watt burns out sooner; one designed to last longer gives less light per watt. The FTC report describes an "inverse relationship between incandescent lamp life and the amount of light given off by a bulb." Cartel members defended 1,000 hours on those grounds, and in 1951 Britain’s Monopolies and Restrictive Practices Commission rejected the planned-obsolescence charge, concluding that any standard life must be a compromise between conflicting factors. The Centennial Light in a Livermore, California, fire station, burning since 1901, is often held up as proof of what bulbs could do; its keepers say it now shines at about 4 watts.

Krajewski is not persuaded by the efficiency defence. In his reading, the evidence points to a cartel driven by profits and sales rather than by what was best for customers.

Still open

The argument still live is about motive: how much of the shorter life was justified by brighter, more efficient light, and how much was about selling more bulbs. Britain’s commission accepted the compromise in 1951; Krajewski reads the evidence as profit-driven. The agreement was meant to run until 1955 and, by his account, was nullified in 1940 when war made coordination impossible. Whether its habits outlasted it, the public record doesn’t say.

Where it stands (for now)

Declassified. The cartel, its 1,000-hour standard and its fines for long-lived bulbs are on the record, along with a 1949 US court ruling that it restricted competition. What remains arguable is how much of the shorter life was justified by brighter, more efficient light, and how much was simply about selling more bulbs.

Sources

  1. News The Great Lightbulb Conspiracy · IEEE Spectrum (Markus Krajewski) · Sept. 23, 2014
  2. Document Staff Report on the Development and Structure of the U.S. Electric Lamp Industry · US Federal Trade Commission, Bureau of Economics (Robert P. Rogers), February 19
  3. Source Livermore’s Centennial Light Facts · Centennial Light (Livermore, California)
  4. Source Phoebus cartel · Wikipedia

More: the case files, every source behind every story.

Talk about it

Start a thread on this story Know more? Send a tip