The Piri Reis map of 1513 and the claim that it shows an ice-free Antarctica
A 1513 Ottoman world map is a real treasure of early cartography, but the claim that its southern coast shows Antarctica without ice rests on a reading that historians of cartography reject.
What’s claimed
In his 1966 book Maps of the Ancient Sea Kings, the American historian Charles Hapgood argued that the southern landmass at the bottom of a 1513 Ottoman world map shows Antarctica as it looked without its ice. If so, someone would have charted that coast long before it was known to Europeans, under conditions that have not existed for millions of years. Hapgood’s case drew support from a US Air Force officer, Lt. Col. Harold Ohlmeyer, who wrote that the lower part of the map agreed "very remarkably" with a seismic profile made across the ice cap by a 1949 expedition.
What’s on the record
The map is genuine and important. The Ottoman admiral and cartographer Piri Reis drew it in 1513 on gazelle-skin parchment; the surviving fragment measures roughly 87 by 63 cm. It was found in the library of Istanbul’s Topkapı Palace in 1929 and is held today by the Topkapı Palace Museum. UNESCO added it to its Memory of the World register in 2017, describing it as the earliest cartographic record of Columbus’s voyages. According to its own legend, it was compiled from about 20 sources, among them maps in the Ptolemaic tradition, Portuguese charts, an Arabic map of India and a map by Christopher Columbus of the West Indies.
UNESCO’s listing also calls it among the earliest works showing Terra Australis. That name is the key to the puzzle. Terra Australis was the great southern continent that geographers had assumed since ancient Greek times, and maps had shown an imagined southern land since the days of Ptolemy.
Antarctica, meanwhile, has been frozen for a very long time. Scientists at Amgueddfa Cymru – National Museum Wales and Cardiff University describe mountain glaciers appearing there around 40 million years ago and a continent-wide ice sheet forming around 34 million years ago.
What doesn’t add up
Gregory C. McIntosh, an independent historian of cartography, translated every inscription on the map and analyzed its place names in a study published by the University of Georgia Press in 2000. He argues that Hapgood assumed his source maps were accurate, adjusted features to fit his hypothesis and ignored the place names written on the map, which made it easy to force a match with modern maps. His conclusion: "There is little or no resemblance between Piri’s southern land and Antarctica, other than the fact that both lie south of the Atlantic Ocean." He reads the southern coast as the long-standing belief in a southern continent blended with Portuguese reports from the east coast of South America.
The ice-cap comparison has its own problem. As the geologist Paul Heinrich has pointed out, it treats the land surface under today’s ice as if it were what an ice-free coast would look like, without allowing for the way land rises once the weight of the ice is gone.
Still open
Only a fragment of the 1513 map survives, so what the rest showed can’t be known. Piri Reis’s own legend names about 20 sources, a Columbus map of the West Indies among them; matching those sources would show exactly what he copied. For the ice-free reading to come back, someone would have to answer McIntosh’s study of the place names and the geology of an ice sheet some 34 million years old.
Where it stands (for now)
Tinfoil. The map is a genuine treasure of the age of exploration. Historians of cartography such as McIntosh find nothing on it that requires knowledge of an ice-free Antarctica, a continent scientists say has carried an ice sheet for some 34 million years; its southern coast fits the old idea of Terra Australis and reports from South America.
Sources
-
Document
The Piri Reis World Map (1513)
· UNESCO Memory of the World
“this map represents the earliest cartographic record of Columbus's oceanic voyages and is among the earliest works showing Terra Australis” - Document The Piri Reis Map of 1513 (Gregory C. McIntosh) · University of Georgia Press · July 6, 2000
-
Source
Columbus and the Piri Reis Map of 1513 (Gregory C. McIntosh, adapted from his book)
· Diego Cuoghi (reprint)
“There is little or no resemblance between Piri's southern land and Antarctica, other than the fact that both lie south of the Atlantic Ocean.” - Source When Antarctica went into the deep freeze · Amgueddfa Cymru – National Museum Wales · May 18, 2008
- Source Piri Reis map · Wikipedia
More: the case files, every source behind every story.