Historical mysteries

The Princes in the Tower: the Missing Princes Project’s documents and the dispute

Edward V and his brother vanished into the Tower of London in 1483; a project led by Philippa Langley says newly found archive papers show they survived, while other historians, including some who found the papers, say they prove no such thing.

Under ReviewSerious people argue both sides; the evidence cuts both ways, and the file stays open.

Published Oct. 16, 2026Last checked Oct. 5, 2026

What’s claimed

The standard story is that Richard III had his nephews, the 12-year-old Edward V and his nine-year-old brother Richard, Duke of York, killed in the Tower of London in 1483 to secure the crown. In November 2023, the writer and producer Philippa Langley, who led the search that found Richard III’s remains under a Leicester car park, said her Missing Princes Project had overturned that story. Its conclusion: both boys survived Richard’s reign, and the two Yorkist pretenders whom Henry VII’s regime cast as impostors, "Lambert Simnel" and "Perkin Warbeck," were in fact Edward and Richard.

What’s on the record

Edward IV died on April 9, 1483. His heir, Edward V, was met on his way to London by his uncle Richard, Duke of Gloucester, and escorted to the Tower; his younger brother was later given up from sanctuary at Westminster and joined him there. Edward was declared deposed on June 25, 1483, after his parents’ marriage was alleged to be invalid, and his uncle took the throne as Richard III. What happened to the boys after that is the mystery.

In 1674, workmen found the bones of children under a staircase in the White Tower. They were assumed to be the princes, and on Charles II’s orders they were placed in an urn in Westminster Abbey; the 1675 royal warrant refers to the "supposed bodyes" of the two princes. The urn was opened in July 1933, when examiners found the incomplete remains of two young children, and resealed.

Langley’s project was formally launched in 2016. Its two headline finds came from members of its Dutch Research Group in 2020. In the archives at Lille, they found a receipt dated December 16, 1487, recording King Maximilian I’s purchase of 400 pikes for Margaret of Burgundy’s nephew, described as a son of her late brother King Edward who had been expelled from his dominion. In the Gelderland archive at Arnhem, they rediscovered a four-page manuscript: a first-person statement in the name of Richard, Duke of York, tracing his story from leaving sanctuary in 1483 to reaching his aunt Margaret’s court in 1493. Langley presented the finds in a Channel 4 documentary with the barrister Rob Rinder and in a book, revised in 2025 under a title declaring the case solved.

What doesn’t add up

Langley says the documents were authenticated by the archives and by independent specialists. The argument is over what they prove. Three leading members of the Dutch Research Group wrote in the Richard III Society’s Ricardian Bulletin in June 2024 that the documents "are in our own opinion open to various interpretations and do not constitute irrefutable proof" that the princes survived. The historian Michael Hicks argued in the journal Historical Research the same year that the Lille receipt cannot establish that the pretender of 1487 was Edward V rather than Edward, Earl of Warwick, and that the Arnhem statement is the kind of story an impostor like Warbeck needed just as much as a real prince would have. He concluded that the new material does not prove either boy lived beyond Richard III’s reign. Langley has replied that her conclusions rest on the totality of the evidence and on police missing-person methods rather than traditional historical method.

The murder story has its own gaps. Langley’s project reports finding no record of the boys’ deaths in the administrative and legal records of Richard III’s reign, and the bones in the Abbey were identified as the princes by assumption.

Still open

The bones in the Westminster Abbey urn, opened in July 1933 and resealed, were named as the princes by assumption, never by proof. The Lille receipt says nephew but gives no name, and the Arnhem statement would serve an impostor as well as a prince. Langley’s project found no record of the boys’ deaths in the records of Richard III’s reign. A document naming the 1487 pretender, or a modern examination of the Abbey bones, would move this file.

Where it stands (for now)

Under Review. The documents are genuine and add to the history of the Yorkist pretenders, and the case that Richard III killed his nephews has never rested on proof either. Whether the princes survived turns on how the new papers are read, and some of the researchers who found them read them more cautiously than Langley does.

Sources

  1. Source Edward V & Richard Duke of York · Westminster Abbey
    “In 1674 some bones of children were found under a staircase in the White Tower in the Tower of London and assumed to be those of the two boys.”
  2. Source Solving the mystery of the Princes in the Tower · The History Press (Philippa Langley)
  3. Video The Princes in the Tower: The New Evidence · Channel 4 · Nov. 17, 2023
  4. Document Historic doubts about the survival of the Princes in the Tower after 1485 · Historical Research (Oxford University Press) · June 20, 2024
  5. Source Philippa Langley · Wikipedia

More: the case files, every source behind every story.

Talk about it

Start a thread on this story Know more? Send a tip