Ancient Egypt & the pyramids

The Sphinx water-erosion theory: a geologist’s older Sphinx and the Egyptologists’ reply

A Boston University geologist argued in the early 1990s that rain, not wind and sand, carved the Sphinx’s deepest weathering and pushed its age back thousands of years; Egyptologists say the quarry and temples tie it to the pharaoh Khafre.

UnconfirmedThin or second-hand evidence so far. Nobody has proven it, and nobody has closed it.

Published Oct. 10, 2026Last checked Oct. 5, 2026

What’s claimed

Egyptologists generally date the Great Sphinx of Giza to the reign of the pharaoh Khafre, around 2500 BCE. Robert Schoch, a geologist at Boston University, says that date is wrong. He first examined the monument in 1990 with the author John Anthony West, and says he found deep fissures and rounded, rippled surfaces on the Sphinx’s body and on the walls of the pit it was carved from that, in his view, only rainfall and run-off could have made. Because the area has been largely dry for about 5,000 years, he concluded that the oldest part of the statue, which he calls the core-body, dates to at least 5000 BCE. He has since pushed his estimate back to around 9700 BCE, near the end of the last ice age, and argues that the Sphinx’s head was recarved in dynastic times.

What’s on the record

Schoch first presented the idea in 1991. In February 1992 he defended it at a science meeting in Chicago, where, according to a Deutsche Presse-Agentur report, he described erosion up to 7.9 feet (about 2.4 metres) deep on the front and sides of the Sphinx and about 3.9 feet at the rear, and cited seismic surveys of the rock beneath the surface. Egyptologist Mark Lehner, then at the University of Chicago, called him a New Age pseudo-scientist and said the Nile valley’s people of that era were "hunters and gatherers wholly incapable of building cities or a monument on the scale of the Sphinx."

Lehner’s case rests on stone. Between 1979 and 1983 he mapped the Sphinx and the temple in front of it block by block, joined from 1980 by geologist Tom Aigner. The temple’s core blocks, some weighing up to 100 tons, carry the same geological layers as the Sphinx’s own bedrock, so they were cut from the ditch around the statue as it was carved. The Sphinx Temple sits beside Khafre’s Valley Temple, where the archaeologist Auguste Mariette found a life-size statue of Khafre in 1853. Luminescence dating of the two temples has given dates in the middle to late third millennium BCE. Lehner wrote in 2017 that Khafre created most of the Sphinx, though Khufu may have started it.

What doesn’t add up

The weathering is real, and geologists disagree about its cause. James Harrell of the University of Toledo and K. Lal Gauri favoured salt crystallization driven by moisture, including dew, rather than heavy rain. Colin Reader, in a 2001 paper in Archaeometry, blamed rainfall run-off rather than rain itself, and Lehner lists him with Schoch among geologists who believe the Sphinx could be older than Khafre. Climate research cited by Lehner suggests the Old Kingdom was wetter than today, with rains tapering off over centuries, which he thinks could explain heavy erosion soon after the Sphinx was carved. Zahi Hawass has argued that Schoch never shows why 4,500 years of rain could not round the corners.

The larger gap is archaeological. Schoch points to Göbekli Tepe in Turkey, about 12,000 years old, as proof that complex culture is older than once thought. Critics such as the archaeologist Kenneth Feder reply that there is no evidence of a culture capable of building the Sphinx much before the accepted date.

Still open

Geologists still disagree on what caused the deep weathering: rain, as Schoch argues; rainfall run-off, as Colin Reader proposed; or salt crystallization driven by moisture, as Harrell and Gauri favoured. Hawass says Schoch never shows why 4,500 years of rain could not do it. The other open door is archaeological: evidence of a culture able to build the Sphinx well before Khafre would change this rating, and none has been found so far.

Where it stands (for now)

Unconfirmed. A credentialed geologist and real weathering patterns started a serious argument about how the enclosure eroded. The leap to a Sphinx thousands of years older than Khafre rests on one contested reading of the rock, while the quarry, the temples and the dating of their stones all point, so far, to the Fourth Dynasty.

Sources

  1. Source Robert M. Schoch: The Great Sphinx · Robert M. Schoch (personal research site)
    “I found heavy erosional features that I concluded could only have been caused by rainfall and water runoff.”
  2. News Sphinx smiles as researchers debate its age · Deseret News (Deutsche Presse-Agentur) · Feb. 22, 1992
  3. Document Who Built the Sphinx? The Sphinx Temple Has the Answer (AERAGRAM 18-1) · Ancient Egypt Research Associates
    “As certain as we can be about such matters, Khafre created most of the Sphinx. However, Khufu might have started it.”
  4. News Uncovering Secrets of the Sphinx · Smithsonian Magazine · Jan. 31, 2010
  5. Source Sphinx water erosion hypothesis · Wikipedia

More: the case files, every source behind every story.

Talk about it

Start a thread on this story Know more? Send a tip