The Vela incident: the 1979 double flash that may have been a secret nuclear test
On September 22, 1979, a US satellite recorded the double flash of an apparent nuclear explosion far to the south of Africa; a White House panel doubted it, other agencies did not, and no government has ever owned up to a test.
What’s claimed
On September 22, 1979, a US satellite built to detect nuclear explosions recorded what looked like one, over remote ocean between southern Africa and Antarctica. The claim is that it was a real, clandestine nuclear test, most often attributed to Israel with South African help, and that Washington played down its own evidence. Neither country has acknowledged a test.
What’s on the record
The satellite was Vela 6911. Its light sensors, called bhangmeters, recorded a double-humped signal, the double flash associated with a nuclear explosion, according to a 2006 National Security Archive briefing book edited by Jeffrey Richelson. The detection raised the possibility that South Africa or Israel, or the two together, had tested in secret.
The Carter White House set up a panel of scientists chaired by Jack Ruina, a former head of the Pentagon’s Advanced Research Projects Agency, with members including Richard Garwin, Luis Alvarez and Wolfgang Panofsky. Its report, dated May 23, 1980, concluded that the signal was probably not from a nuclear detonation, and pointed instead to a small meteoroid striking the satellite. That became the closest thing to an official public verdict.
Others inside the government disagreed. The Defense Intelligence Agency, the national laboratories and contractors concluded that the satellite had detected a nuclear detonation. A Naval Research Laboratory study of ocean sound data reached the same conclusion; it has never been declassified, and in 2019 the National Security Archive reported that the laboratory could not locate it. According to a 2020 Wilson Center report by Avner Cohen and William Burr, the Navy analysis pointed to a low-yield explosion near the Prince Edward Islands in the sub-Antarctic Indian Ocean. Scientists at the Arecibo Observatory also detected an unusual travelling disturbance in the ionosphere at the time.
Privately, President Jimmy Carter leaned the other way. On February 27, 1980, he wrote in his diary of "a growing belief among our scientists that the Israelis did indeed conduct a nuclear test explosion."
The other side
Later research has leaned toward a test. In 2018, Lars-Erik De Geer and Christopher Wright argued in Science & Global Security that radionuclide and hydroacoustic data support a low-yield nuclear explosion, citing iodine-131 found in the thyroids of sheep slaughtered in Australia in October 1979. In 2019, they and other researchers wrote in Foreign Policy that the documents and science now firmly support the nuclear explanation.
But the record is not complete. At a 2019 Wilson Center oral-history conference, former officials remained divided, some still holding to "not proven." South Africa, as its former scientists later acknowledged, was not in a position to conduct such a test at the time; Israel, the country most often named, has never acknowledged one.
Still open
The Naval Research Laboratory study of ocean sound data, which concluded the satellite saw a nuclear detonation, has never been declassified, and in 2019 the laboratory said it could not locate it. No country has acknowledged a test. The White House panel’s 1980 doubt has never been formally replaced, and former officials at a 2019 conference were still divided. That Navy study, if it can be found and released, would move this rating.
Where it stands (for now)
Redacted. The flash and the internal disagreement are documented, and the weight of later analysis favours a nuclear test. But the key Navy study remains unreleased, no country has admitted a test, and the White House panel’s doubt has never been formally replaced.
Sources
-
Document
The Vela Flash: Forty Years Ago
· National Security Archive, George Washington University · Sept. 21, 2019
“We have a growing belief among our scientists that the Israelis did indeed conduct a nuclear test explosion” -
Document
The Vela Incident: Nuclear Test or Meteorite?
· National Security Archive, George Washington University · May 4, 2006
“The study concluded that the Vela 6911 signal most probably resulted from a nuclear detonation.” - Document The 22 September 1979 Vela Incident: Radionuclide and Hydroacoustic Evidence for a Nuclear Explosion · Science & Global Security
- Document Revisiting the 1979 VELA Mystery: A Report on a Critical Oral History Conference · Wilson Center · Aug. 30, 2020
- News Blast From the Past · Foreign Policy · Sept. 21, 2019
More: the case files, every source behind every story.