Thule, 1968, and Project Crested Ice: the B-52 crash and Denmark’s nuclear secret
In January 1968 a B-52 with four H-bombs crashed on the ice near Thule, Greenland. The cleanup, Crested Ice, later exposed Denmark’s secret 1957 nod to US nuclear weapons in Greenland.
What’s claimed
On January 21, 1968, an American B-52 carrying four hydrogen bombs crashed onto sea ice near Thule Air Base in northwest Greenland. The Thule accident, its cleanup (Project or Operation Crested Ice) and the political storm that followed in Denmark, known as the Thule affair, are said to hide two secrets: that one bomb was never fully recovered, and that Denmark, officially nuclear-free, had secretly let the United States bring nuclear weapons into Greenland.
What’s on the record
The bomber, call sign HOBO 28, was carrying four Mark 28 thermonuclear bombs. A crew member had stuffed seat cushions in front of a heating vent; they caught fire, the smoke grew too thick, and six of the seven men aboard parachuted out. The plane hit the frozen surface of Wolstenholme Fjord about seven miles west of the base, Timothy Jorgensen of Georgetown University writes in Scientific American. The bombs’ conventional explosives went off, but there was no nuclear blast. American airmen walked the ice in long lines to pick up wreckage, and contaminated ice and snow were loaded into sealed tanks; Danish base workers took part too.
Denmark’s own policy banned nuclear weapons on its territory. But in 1994 Foreign Ministry officials found files showing that on November 18, 1957, Prime Minister H. C. Hansen had answered the US ambassador’s question about nuclear weapons in Greenland with a secret letter saying, in effect, that Denmark did not wish to be asked, according to the Danish national encyclopedia Lex. At least 48 warheads for Nike-Hercules missiles were stationed at Thule between 1959 and 1965. Foreign Minister Niels Helveg Petersen told parliament’s foreign policy committee in June 1995. Greenland’s own council had never been told.
That November about 1,700 former Thule workers each received 50,000 kroner. The government called it an ex gratia payment, not an admission of liability. A government-commissioned study found cancer rates among the cleanup workers 40 per cent higher than among other base workers but could not link the difference to radiation, the Copenhagen Post reported; Lex notes other health studies found no documented increase.
What doesn’t add up
The missing-bomb question will not die. A secondary-stage cylinder from one weapon was never recovered, and a search of the seabed by a small submarine found nothing. In 2008 the BBC, citing declassified US documents, reported that investigators could account for only three of the four weapons, and that the submarine’s real purpose was kept from Greenland officials. Denmark asked its Institute for International Studies to investigate. Its 2009 report by Svend Aage Christensen answered in its title: "There is no bomb, there was no bomb, they were not looking for a bomb." In that account, the search was for a weapon component, not a whole bomb.
Still open
A secondary-stage cylinder from one weapon was never recovered, and the small submarine’s seabed search found nothing. The BBC, citing declassified US documents, said the submarine’s real purpose was kept from Greenland officials; Denmark’s 2009 report said the search was for a part, not a bomb. Whether the cleanup made workers sick is unsettled: one study found cancer rates 40 per cent higher but could not link them to radiation, and other studies found no documented increase.
Where it stands (for now)
Declassified. The crash, the cleanup, the secret 1957 letter and the 1995 compensation are on the record. Denmark’s own inquiry found no intact bomb off Thule, and none has surfaced; what was lost, by both sides’ accounts, is a part that was never recovered.
Sources
- News 50 Years Ago a U.S. Military Jet Crashed in Greenland, with 4 Nuclear Bombs Onboard · Scientific American (from The Conversation) · Jan. 19, 2018
- Source Thulesagen: sag om kernevåben i Grønland · Lex, Danmarks Nationalleksikon
- News Broken Arrow meets Erin Brockovich in Thulegate · The Copenhagen Post · June 28, 2016
- News US lost nuke under Greenland ice · The Register · Nov. 11, 2008
- Document The Marshal’s Baton: There is no bomb, there was no bomb, they were not looking for a bomb · Danish Institute for International Studies
More: the case files, every source behind every story.