Tom Thomson’s death at Canoe Lake, 1917: the drowning ruling, the bruise and the 1956 dig
Painter Tom Thomson vanished on Canoe Lake in July 1917; an inquest ruled accidental drowning, but a head wound, a hurried inquest and a 1956 grave dig keep murder theories alive.
What’s claimed
Tom Thomson, the painter of The West Wind and The Jack Pine and an inspiration for the Group of Seven, died on Canoe Lake in Algonquin Park, Ontario, in July 1917, aged 39. The official verdict was accidental drowning. Many people have never accepted it. They argue that a skilled canoeist and woodsman could not simply have drowned, and suggest murder over a debt, a woman or the war, or suicide. A further claim is that his body never left Algonquin Park.
What’s on the record
Thomson set out alone across Canoe Lake around midday on Sunday, July 8, 1917, his canoe loaded with fishing gear. That afternoon the canoe was seen floating upside down. His body surfaced on July 16.
Two first-hand records describe it, and they disagree. Dr. G.W. Howland, a Toronto physician who saw the body in the water, swore in an affidavit dated July 17 that it was a man of about 40 in an advanced state of decomposition, with a four-inch bruise on the right temple, bleeding from the right ear and no other marks; cause of death, drowning. Park ranger Mark Robinson’s journal for the same day records a four-inch bruise on the left temple, apparently from a fall on a rock, and notes that the body was buried that day in the small cemetery at Canoe Lake on the superintendent’s orders. The coroner arrived from North Bay that evening, after the burial, and took evidence; Robinson wrote that residents were openly critical of how it was done. The verdict was accidental drowning. The Dictionary of Canadian Biography calls the inquest hurried.
A steel casket was then sent in. The body was exhumed and reburied in the family plot at Leith, near Owen Sound, on July 21, The Canadian Encyclopedia says.
In 1956, William Little and friends dug at the old Canoe Lake cemetery and found a skeleton in the area where Thomson was first buried. Dr. Noble Sharpe, who examined the bones for the Ontario authorities, supervised their removal on October 5. His report of October 30, 1956, describes a man about five foot eight, aged 20 to 30, judged by a University of Toronto professor to be Indigenous. A hole in the left temple was, on X-ray, a surgical trephine opening, not a bullet wound. Thomson, Sharpe noted, was described in books as over six feet tall and about 40. Sharpe concluded he felt “definitely that the skeleton is not that of Mr. Thomson.”
What doesn’t add up
Sharpe’s own report admits there was nothing to prove the grave he opened was not Thomson’s original one, and he wrote that only opening the Leith grave would end the rumours. The record is full of gaps: a bruise on the right temple or the left, an inquest held after the burial, and lingering questions about whether the body was really moved. In a 1977 Toronto Star article and a 2010 book, journalist Roy MacGregor argued that Thomson was killed by the lodge owner Shannon Fraser, based on a story said to have come from Fraser’s wife; that account is second-hand and was never tested. Gregory Klages, research director of the Great Unsolved Mysteries in Canadian History site, lays out theories ranging from bad luck on a lake full of logging debris to suicide and foul play. None has been proven.
Still open
Where Thomson lies has never been settled: Sharpe admitted nothing proved the grave he opened was not Thomson’s first one, and wrote that only opening the Leith grave would end the rumours. The bruise is on the right temple in the doctor’s affidavit and on the left in the ranger’s journal. Who the skeleton found in 1956 belonged to is unknown. The Fraser account is second-hand and was never tested.
Where it stands (for now)
Under Review. The accidental drowning ruling still stands, but the inquest was hurried and the two first-hand records contradict each other on the wound. The murder theories rest on hearsay recalled decades later, and serious writers still disagree on what happened, and even on where Thomson lies.
Sources
- Source Death on a Painted Lake: The Tom Thomson Tragedy · Great Unsolved Mysteries in Canadian History
-
Document
Copy of Dr. G. W. Howland’s affidavit, July 17, 1917
· Great Unsolved Mysteries in Canadian History (from Library and Archives Canada) · July 16, 1917
“was a bruise on right temple size of 4" long” - Document Mark Robinson’s daily journal, July 16–18, 1917 · Great Unsolved Mysteries in Canadian History (from Trent University Archives)
-
Document
Dr. Noble Sharpe, Re: Human Bones received from unmarked grave in Algonquin Park, Oct. 30, 1956
· Great Unsolved Mysteries in Canadian History (from the Centre for Forensic Scien · Oct. 29, 1956
“But I feel definitely that the skeleton is not that of Mr. Thomson.” - Document THOMSON, THOMAS JOHN (Tom) · Dictionary of Canadian Biography
- Source Tom Thomson · The Canadian Encyclopedia (Historica Canada) · Aug. 26, 2013
More: the case files, every source behind every story.