Ships, seas & the deep

USS Scorpion: what sank the US submarine lost near the Azores in 1968?

USS Scorpion vanished with 99 men in May 1968. The Navy’s court favoured an explosion, its admirals would not commit, and one journalist says a Soviet submarine sank her.

Under ReviewSerious people argue both sides; the evidence cuts both ways, and the file stays open.

Published Oct. 18, 2026Last checked Oct. 18, 2026

What’s claimed

USS Scorpion (SSN-589), a Skipjack-class nuclear attack submarine, was lost with all 99 men aboard in May 1968 while heading home to Norfolk, Virginia, from the Mediterranean. The US Navy has never said for certain what sank her. The most dramatic answer, set out by the journalist Ed Offley in his 2007 book Scorpion Down, is that a Soviet submarine attacked her, perhaps in revenge for the loss of the Soviet submarine K-129 two months earlier, and that the Pentagon buried the truth.

What’s on the record

According to the Navy’s Dictionary of American Naval Fighting Ships, Scorpion reported her position on May 21 about 50 miles south of the Azores. Offley and other accounts date the sinking to May 22. Six days after her report she was overdue at Norfolk, and after a vast air and sea search she was declared presumed lost on June 5. At the end of October the research ship Mizar found her broken hull in more than 10,000 feet of water about 400 miles southwest of the Azores. A court of inquiry heard 76 witnesses that summer and reconvened after the wreck was found. In January 1969 the Navy announced that the certain cause of the loss could not be ascertained from the evidence available.

The court’s full findings, declassified in 1993, said more. Writing in Naval History in 2025, Offley quotes its view, based on acoustic evidence and photographs of the hull, that the likeliest cause was “an explosion of large charge weight external to the pressure hull.” Told by fleet officials that no Soviet submarines were nearby, the court built a scenario in which one of Scorpion’s own Mark 37 torpedoes began running in its tube, was released, armed itself and turned back on her. The Atlantic submarine commander, Vice Admiral Arnold Schade, argued instead for a flooding accident. The Atlantic Fleet commander, Admiral Holmes, set the court’s explosion finding aside, and the Chief of Naval Operations, Admiral Thomas Moorer, endorsed only the verdict that the cause could not be known.

The other side

Offley’s case is that Scorpion had been diverted to watch Soviet warships near the Canary Islands, that the Navy feared she was lost within a day and quietly began searching before it admitted she was missing, and that former Navy personnel have told him a Soviet submarine sank her. Critics reject it. John Craven, who headed the Navy’s Deep Submergence Systems Project and helped locate the wreck from underwater sound recordings, called the book “wrong and irresponsible” in 2007; his team had blamed an accident with a torpedo warhead.

A third answer came from Bruce Rule, described by the naval analyst Norman Polmar as the Navy’s top acoustic analyst. Rule’s book, reviewed in The Submarine Review in 2012, concluded that hydrogen given off by Scorpion’s main battery exploded twice, incapacitating the crew, and that the hull later collapsed at about 1,530 feet. Polmar called the Soviet-torpedo idea the most ridiculous of the theories. Part of the record is still classified, which keeps every camp going.

Still open

Part of the record is still classified, which keeps every camp going. The court’s explosion finding was set aside by the admirals above it, and the Navy settled on a cause that could not be ascertained. Offley’s claim that the Navy began searching before it admitted she was missing, and his sources’ account of a Soviet attack, haven’t been tested in public against the full files. Release of the rest could show which camp the evidence favours.

Where it stands (for now)

Under Review. The Navy’s own court favoured an explosion outside the hull, the admirals above it would not commit, and later experts blame a torpedo or the battery. The claim of a Soviet attack rests on the accounts of former Navy personnel, and part of the record that could test it is still classified.

Sources

  1. Document Scorpion VI (SSN-589) · Naval History and Heritage Command (DANFS)
  2. News The USS Scorpion: Buried at Sea · Naval History (US Naval Institute)
    “an explosion of large charge weight external to the pressure hull”
  3. News Expert torpedoes book on USS Scorpion · Honolulu Star-Bulletin · June 16, 2007
  4. Source Re: Loss of USS Scorpion (Norman Polmar) · The Submarine Review (Naval Submarine League)

More: the case files, every source behind every story.

Talk about it

Start a thread on this story Know more? Send a tip