Phosphine on Venus: the 2020 ‘sign of life’ detection and the fight over the data
In September 2020 astronomers reported phosphine, a possible sign of life, in the clouds of Venus; re-analyses found a data error and a weaker or no signal, and a 2024 follow-up is unsettled.
What’s claimed
On September 14, 2020, a team led by Jane Greaves reported in Nature Astronomy that it had found phosphine (PH3), a gas linked on Earth to living things, in the cloud decks of Venus. Using the James Clerk Maxwell Telescope (JCMT) and the Atacama Large Millimeter/submillimeter Array (ALMA), they inferred about 20 parts per billion. Finding no known non-biological way to make that much phosphine on Venus, they wrote that it could come from unknown chemistry or, by analogy with Earth, “from the presence of life.” The headlines wrote themselves: life in the clouds of Venus.
What’s on the record
The detection rested on a single spectral line near 267 gigahertz, observed with the JCMT in June 2017 and with ALMA in March 2019. Within weeks it was challenged. Snellen and colleagues re-processed the ALMA data and found that the 12th-order polynomial used to flatten the spectrum could produce false lines; they saw only a weak feature, not a significant detection.
In November 2020 the team told Nature Astronomy about an error in the original processing of the ALMA data, and the journal added an editor’s note cautioning readers about the ALMA figures. Greaves’s team re-analysed the recalibrated data and still reported phosphine, now at a planet-wide average of about one to four parts per billion, with local peaks of five to 10.
In July 2021 Nature Astronomy published a response by Geronimo Villanueva and colleagues, who argued that a sulphur dioxide line sits very close to the phosphine line and could explain the signal; the Greaves team replied that the JCMT line was too broad to be sulphur dioxide. In November 2021 an airborne observatory, SOFIA, looked for other phosphine lines over three flights and found none, setting an upper limit of 0.8 parts per billion at heights of 75 to 110 kilometres.
The story did not end there. Chemistry World reported in August 2024 that a team led by Dave Clements of Imperial College London, a co-author of the 2020 paper, announced at the UK’s National Astronomy Meeting in July that a large body of new data had found phosphine again, along with ammonia deeper in the clouds. Those results had not yet been peer-reviewed.
What doesn’t add up
Each side has a point. The signal is faint, sits beside a confusing sulphur dioxide line and has shrunk as the data were cleaned. The SOFIA limit covers high altitudes, which leaves room to argue about lower layers. And even a confirmed detection would not mean life: the original paper itself listed unknown photochemistry or geochemistry as possibilities.
Still open
The 2024 detection reported by Dave Clements’s team, with ammonia deeper in the clouds, had not been peer-reviewed when Chemistry World wrote it up. SOFIA’s upper limit covers heights of 75 to 110 kilometres, which leaves the lower cloud layers open to argument. And even a confirmed detection would leave the source unknown: the original paper itself listed unknown photochemistry or geochemistry as possibilities alongside life.
Where it stands (for now)
Under Review. Serious teams have published on both sides, a processing error weakened the original result, and the newest claim of a detection is not yet peer-reviewed. Phosphine on Venus is unconfirmed so far, and life on Venus is further off still.
Sources
- Document Phosphine gas in the cloud decks of Venus (Greaves et al.) · Nature Astronomy · Sept. 13, 2020
- Document Re-analysis of the 267-GHz ALMA observations of Venus: No statistically significant detection of phosphine (Snellen et al.) · arXiv · Oct. 18, 2020
- Document Re-analysis of Phosphine in Venus’ Clouds (Greaves et al.) · arXiv · Nov. 15, 2020
- Document No evidence of phosphine in the atmosphere of Venus by independent analyses (Villanueva et al.) · arXiv · Oct. 26, 2020
- Document Phosphine in the Venusian Atmosphere: A Strict Upper Limit from SOFIA GREAT Observations (Cordiner et al., Geophysical Research Letters) · arXiv · Oct. 23, 2022
- News Controversial phosphine findings on Venus corroborated · Chemistry World (Royal Society of Chemistry) · Aug. 28, 2024
More: the case files, every source behind every story.