Who Killed the Electric Car? GM’s EV1, California’s mandate and the crushed cars
GM leased its EV1 electric car in California from 1996, then recalled and crushed most of them. A 2006 film blamed GM, oil and regulators; GM blamed weak demand and a billion dollars in costs.
What’s claimed
The EV1 was General Motors’ modern electric car, leased to drivers in California from 1996. By 2003 the cars were off the road and most had been destroyed. The 2006 documentary Who Killed the Electric Car?, by the director Chris Paine, a former EV1 driver, argued that the car worked, that people wanted it, and that it was smothered by carmakers, oil interests and a state regulator that bowed to them. The title has since become shorthand for the idea that the auto industry buried a technology that threatened its business.
What’s on the record
The EV1 existed because of a rule. In 1990 the California Air Resources Board adopted a zero-emission vehicle requirement: at least 2 percent of new cars sold by major carmakers were to be zero-emitting by 1998, 5 percent by 2001 and 10 percent by 2003. The board expected battery cars to meet it. In 1996 it dropped the interim targets for 1998 to 2002, kept the 10 percent goal, and signed agreements with the seven largest carmakers to put several thousand zero-emission vehicles on California roads.
GM began leasing the EV1 that year. It would not sell them, because it considered the car experimental technology. In 2002 GM joined other companies in a lawsuit challenging the mandate, and in June that year a federal judge barred the board from enforcing its 2001 amendments for the 2003 and 2004 model years. The board relaxed the rules in 2003. When the leases ran out, GM recalled the cars and most were demolished. In June 2006, shortly before the film opened, the Smithsonian’s National Museum of American History took its donated EV1 off display; the museum said it needed the space, and GM denied any connection.
The other side
GM’s explanation is demand and money. Its spokesman Dave Barthmuss told NPR in 2006 that the EV1 was a tremendous technical achievement but would appeal only to a small number of people, that GM had spent well over $1 billion and could not afford to lose more, and that fewer than a thousand customers had leased it. He told The Washington Post there was no “Oliver Stone-esque conspiracy” to do away with the car. Former EV1 sales staff said they built a waiting list to prove demand, and activists put it at 5,000 names; Barthmuss said only a fraction of those would commit when pressed. The business historian David Kirsch of the University of Maryland told NPR that GM treated the recall as an ordinary business decision without realizing it had found a new kind of customer. And in June 2006 GM’s chief executive, Rick Wagoner, told Motor Trend that the decision he most regretted was axing the EV1 and not putting the right resources into hybrids, which he said hurt GM’s image rather than its profits.
Still open
GM’s reasoning is known mainly through its spokesman and its chief executive. GM said fewer than a thousand customers leased the car; former sales staff built a waiting list that activists put at 5,000 names, and how many would have signed was never tested in a sale, because GM would not sell. GM denied any connection to the Smithsonian taking its EV1 off display, and the museum said it needed the space.
Where it stands (for now)
Under Review. The mandate, the lawsuit, the recall and the crushing are documented. Whether the EV1 was killed to protect GM’s gasoline-car business, or dropped as a money-loser once regulators stopped requiring it, is still argued, and GM’s own chief executive later called the decision a mistake.
Sources
- News Movie Plumbs the Demise of the Electric Car · NPR (Weekend Edition) · June 30, 2006
- Document Initial Statement of Reasons: 2003 Proposed Amendments to the California Zero Emission Vehicle Regulations · California Air Resources Board
- News Smithsonian dumps electric car exhibit · NBC News (AP) · June 18, 2006
- News GM CEO admits killing electric car was a blunder · Grist · June 28, 2006
- Document Zero-emission Vehicle Regulation · California Air Resources Board
More: the case files, every source behind every story.