The Yeti: Shipton’s 1951 footprint, the Khumjung scalp and the DNA that found bears
The Yeti’s best relics have been tested: the Khumjung scalp was serow hide, and DNA studies in 2014 and 2017 traced “Yeti” hair, bone and skin to Himalayan bears and one dog.
What’s claimed
The Yeti, also called the Abominable Snowman, is said to be an ape-like creature living in the high Himalayas of Nepal and Tibet. The word is usually translated as “wild man.” Supporters point to giant footprints in the snow, eyewitness accounts and relics kept in Buddhist monasteries, and argue that an unknown primate survives in some of the most remote country on Earth.
What’s on the record
Western interest grew with the race for Everest. Atlas Obscura recounts that during the 1921 Everest reconnaissance, Charles Howard-Bury reported large footprints that his guides attributed to “metch kangmi,” and the press mistranslated the phrase as “abominable snowman.”
The defining picture came in 1951. Eric Shipton and Michael Ward, looking for another route up Everest, found a line of prints on the Menlung Glacier near the Nepal–Tibet border. Shipton photographed one beside an ice axe for scale. In an interview with National Geographic, Yeti researcher Daniel Taylor described a print about 13 inches long that looked human but had what seemed to be a thumb. The photo set off a string of expeditions, including the Daily Mail’s in 1954.
In the fall of 1960, Edmund Hillary and zoologist Marlin Perkins examined the Yeti scalp kept for more than two centuries at the monastery in Khumjung. According to the Explorers Club account quoted by Atlas Obscura, Perkins concluded it could not be scalp tissue. With the permission of the village elders and Nepal’s government, the scalp travelled to the United States, France and Britain, and the scientists who examined it agreed it had been shaped from the hide of a serow, a Himalayan goat-antelope. It went back to Khumjung.
DNA came next. In 2014, Oxford geneticist Bryan Sykes and colleagues published tests on hair attributed to “anomalous primates.” National Geographic reported that one Yeti hair came from a serow and two matched a polar bear sequence more than 40,000 years old, which Sykes suggested might mean an unknown bear. In 2015, Pensoft reported, C.J. Edwards and R. Barnett showed the matching sequence came from a modern Alaskan polar bear, and Eliécer Gutiérrez and Ronald Pine argued in ZooKeys that the fragment was too short to tell polar from brown bears, so there was no reason to think the hairs came from anything but Himalayan brown bears.
In November 2017, a team led by Charlotte Lindqvist of the University at Buffalo published an analysis of nine “Yeti” specimens in Proceedings of the Royal Society B. Bone, tooth, skin, hair and droppings were tested. One was from a dog. The other eight were bears: an Asian black bear, a Himalayan brown bear and six Tibetan brown bears. A piece of skin from a monastery relic was black bear; a femur from a cave in Tibet was brown bear. “Clearly, a big part of the Yeti legend has to do with bears,” Lindqvist said.
What doesn’t add up
Every object put forward as a piece of a Yeti has, when tested, come from a known animal. Taylor, who spent decades on the trail, came to think the human-like prints were left by Asian black bears. The samples Lindqvist tested were supplied by a television production company, so they are not a complete survey. But no expedition has produced a body, bone or clear photograph of an unknown ape. Taylor also notes that Hillary’s team separated the Sherpa belief in the Yeti from the Western hunt for a hominid; they are not the same thing.
Still open
The samples Lindqvist tested were supplied by a television production company, so they are not a complete survey of what is out there. Shipton’s 1951 print, with what seemed to be a thumb, survives as a photograph; Taylor came to think such prints were made by Asian black bears. A body, a bone or a clear photograph of an unknown ape would change this rating. No expedition has produced one.
Where it stands (for now)
Tinfoil. Every relic, hair and bone tested so far has come back bear, serow or dog. The Yeti as part of Himalayan belief is real; the Yeti as an unknown ape has no evidence behind it yet.
Sources
- News This Man Searched for the Yeti for 60 Years—and Found It · National Geographic · Aug. 18, 2017
- Source Objects of Intrigue: Yeti Scalp · Atlas Obscura · May 29, 2013
- News “Bigfoot” Unmasked · National Geographic · July 15, 2014
- Source No reason to believe yeti legends to be inspired by an unknown type of bear · Pensoft Publishers · March 15, 2015
- News Abominable Snowman? Nope. Study ties DNA samples from purported Yetis to Asian bears · University at Buffalo · Nov. 27, 2017
More: the case files, every source behind every story.