The Yonaguni monument: Japan’s underwater ‘pyramid’ and the geologists who doubt it
Off Japan’s Yonaguni island, giant stone steps lie 25 metres down; one marine geologist calls them a sunken city, while most geologists see sandstone that split naturally.
What’s claimed
The Yonaguni monument, sometimes called the Yonaguni underwater pyramid or "Japan’s Atlantis," is a mass of stepped rock off Yonaguni Jima, near the southern tip of Japan’s Ryukyu chain, about 120 kilometres east of Taiwan. A local diver first noticed the formations in 1986; Kihachiro Aratake, a director of the island’s tourism association, was looking for hammerhead sharks when he saw what looked like architecture on the sea floor. A headland on the island was soon nicknamed Iseki Hanto, or Ruins Point.
The leading advocate of a human origin is Masaaki Kimura, a marine geologist at the University of the Ryukyus who dived the site for more than 15 years. He describes terraces, steps, straight walls and a stepped pyramid rising from about 25 metres down, plus carvings he reads as animals and faces. "I think it’s very difficult to explain away their origin as being purely natural," he told National Geographic in 2007. Some have linked the site to Mu, a legendary Pacific continent said to have sunk beneath the waves.
What’s on the record
Kimura reports 10 structures off Yonaguni and five related ones off Okinawa, spread over an area of about 300 by 150 metres. His dating has shifted. He first put the formation at 10,000 years or more, when sea levels were lower and it would have stood on dry land. National Geographic reported in 2007 that he dated the ruins to at least 5,000 years, partly from stalactites in underwater caves, and that charcoal from similar structures on the nearby coast dated to about 1,600 years ago. In a 2007 report to the 21st Pacific Science Congress he proposed an age of 2,000 to 3,000 years, with earthquakes later dropping the site underwater. At least one other academic, Toru Ouchi of Kobe University, has sided with him.
Robert Schoch, a geologist at Boston University who dived the site, disagrees. "It’s basic geology and classic stratigraphy for sandstones," he told National Geographic: the rock breaks along flat planes and gives very straight edges, especially in an area full of faults and earthquakes. On his own website he concludes the structure is primarily natural, perhaps more than 95 per cent, while allowing that ancient people may have touched parts of it up. The German geologist Wolf Wichmann, who studied the formations during a 1999 expedition, also concluded natural processes could have formed them. Schoch and Patrick Nunn of the University of the South Pacific point to similar step-like formations on land at Sanninudai that are accepted as purely natural.
What doesn’t add up
No excavation has turned up tools, inscriptions or building debris accepted by other archaeologists, and Kimura’s case rests largely on his own interpretation of shapes. The carvings he describes look to critics like natural scratches, and seeing faces in rock is a well-known trap. Neither Japan’s Agency for Cultural Affairs nor Okinawa Prefecture recognises the site as an important cultural property, and neither has carried out research or preservation work there. The formations are officially owned by the local district, and divers may visit freely. On the other side, Schoch himself leaves room for some human modification, so the question is not quite all or nothing.
Still open
No excavation has produced tools, inscriptions or building debris accepted by other archaeologists, and neither Japan’s Agency for Cultural Affairs nor Okinawa Prefecture has carried out research or preservation work at the site. Kimura’s own dating has moved from 10,000 years or more to 2,000 to 3,000. Schoch allows that people may have touched parts of it up. An official survey, or a worked tool from the site, would move this rating.
Where it stands (for now)
Unconfirmed. The stone steps are real and striking, but the case for a sunken city rests on one researcher’s readings and a few supporters, while most geologists who have looked see sandstone that split along natural joints.
Sources
- News Japan’s Ancient Underwater “Pyramid” Mystifies Scholars · National Geographic · Sept. 18, 2007
-
Source
The Underwater Monument at Yonaguni, Japan
· Robert M. Schoch (Boston University geologist)
“I do not believe it is an artificial, human-made structure.” - News Exploration Mysteries: Yonaguni Monument · ExplorersWeb · April 26, 2023
- Source Yonaguni Monument · Wikipedia
More: the case files, every source behind every story.