The Younger Dryas impact hypothesis: did a comet strike 12,900 years ago?
In 2007 scientists proposed that a comet broke up over North America 12,900 years ago, plunging the world back into the cold. Critics call it refuted; its backers keep publishing.
What’s claimed
About 12,900 years ago, as the last Ice Age was ending, much of the Northern Hemisphere was thrown back into deep cold for roughly 1,200 years, with parts of it up to 8 degrees Celsius colder than today. Geologists call this the Younger Dryas. The Younger Dryas impact hypothesis, often shortened to YDIH and sometimes called the Clovis comet theory, holds that a comet or its fragments exploded over or struck North America at that moment, setting off wildfires, disturbing the ice sheet, triggering the cold and helping to finish off mammoths and the Clovis culture. Graham Hancock went further in his 2015 book Magicians of the Gods and in his 2022 Netflix series Ancient Apocalypse, whose eighth episode covered the idea, tying the catastrophe to a lost Ice Age civilization.
What’s on the record
The hypothesis entered the scientific literature in 2007, when a team led by Richard Firestone of Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory proposed it in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences. They reported a thin layer at North American sites, often in dark "black mat" soils, holding magnetic microspherules, nanodiamonds and other proposed impact markers. Because no crater of that age was known, they suggested the impactor had broken up and exploded in the air.
Independent checks followed. Some researchers could not find the spherules and nanodiamonds; others questioned whether the layers at different sites were really the same age. Mark Boslough, a physicist at the University of New Mexico, argued that a fragmented comet would leave pieces either too small to do much harm or too big not to leave craters. The proponents, led by Allen West, kept publishing, and in 2016 formed a non-profit, the Comet Research Group. In 2018 they released papers on ice-core and sediment evidence for continent-wide burning.
In 2023 Earth-Science Reviews published a "comprehensive refutation" by Vance Holliday and 12 co-authors. They found no crater dating to the onset of the Younger Dryas, said most of the markers come from ordinary processes on Earth, and concluded the hypothesis should be rejected. The Hiawatha crater under Greenland’s ice, once floated as a candidate, was dated in 2022 to about 58 million years ago. On 11 February 2026 PLOS One retracted two 2025 papers by the group; one notice said samples identified as comet dust were in fact marine plankton. The group’s Christopher Moore said it remained confident in its data.
The other side
Most researchers favour a more earthly trigger: meltwater from the North American ice sheet and glacial lakes pouring into the North Atlantic and disrupting ocean currents. Holliday argues the comet answers an archaeological problem that does not exist, since Folsom spear points follow Clovis points with no gap, and the big animals died out at different times around the world. Supporters reply that the markers line up at the same moment when they are dated the same way.
Still open
No crater dating to the start of the Younger Dryas has been found; the Hiawatha crater under Greenland’s ice turned out to be about 58 million years old. The two sides still disagree on whether the markers line up at the same moment, and supporters say they do when dated the same way. A crater of the right age, or markers confirmed by independent teams, would shift this file.
Where it stands (for now)
Under Review. The cold snap is real and its cause is still argued in the journals, where a minority keeps publishing evidence for an impact. Most relevant experts reject it, a 2023 review called for it to be dropped, and recent retractions have not helped. Hancock’s lost civilization is a separate claim archaeologists do not accept.
Sources
- News Why won’t this debate about an ancient cold snap die? · Science News · June 25, 2018
-
Document
Comprehensive refutation of the Younger Dryas Impact Hypothesis (YDIH)
· Earth-Science Reviews (via Royal Holloway, University of London) · July 25, 2023
“No craters have been identified that date to the onset of the Younger Dryas.” - News The mysterious Hiawatha crater in Greenland is 58 million years old · Science News · March 8, 2022
- News Controversial comet theory struck by two new retractions · Retraction Watch · March 3, 2026
- News Did a Comet Really Chill and Kill Clovis Culture? · Live Science · Feb. 27, 2013
- Source Younger Dryas impact hypothesis · Wikipedia
More: the case files, every source behind every story.